An 8.5 for me the now [...] but its the keepers stopping it from a 9 or 9.5 they just seem to robotic /too clinical not human enough and especially on Superstar and even Top player.
I would agree with this, but I think it's shooting more than superhuman goalkeepers - though it's a combination of both.
When I score,
if I feel joy, it's because I've got through the grind of creating a chance versus 10 men behind the ball -
not because of how great the shot is. The video I posted earlier is the first goal in, I don't know, 30 goals maybe, that I've considered worthy of recording.
In my opinion, and
every PES is the same (going back to the beginning) - your shot is
so clearly less about your input and your contextual interaction with the ball, and more "you're not supposed to score, so your striker hits it straight at the keeper".
Almost like Dungeons & Dragons football where you've got a beardy bloke going "
mwahahaaa, you tried to score, but
yet again you were thwarted!"
In one of the few matches I dominated in the ML, I had 20 shots. 7 were on target, but straight at the keeper. 13 were off-target and all hit the exact same spot, i.e. they missed by exactly the same degree. I lost 3-0 to the AI, all three goals counter-attacks, and I was ready to kill someone.
IMO, shot input is limited to three things - "straight at keeper", "six yards wide", "goal". With very, very little in-between.
This has stopped me from enjoying PES for a
long time, but this year, the general gameplay and AI has been improved enough for me to enjoy it despite of this stuff.
In-fact, that's my overriding feeling - I'm enjoying this game
despite of a hell of a lot of stuff. The awful presentation, cartoon player faces, "kill me now" commentary that's five years old, archaic animations that see players stop dead in the middle of runs and/or "stumble" when touched, not enough pass error (and sorry, the ball is NOT free, it 100% has to magnetise to someone after any deflection or tackle), zero shot variety and slightly superhuman keepers.
All of that stuff is utter garbage. But the good stuff... is
really good.
(Of course, there will be certain people who say "solve shooting by using advanced/manual shooting". I can't get used to advanced - if I could flip the directions around I could, but otherwise, no, it's like being right-handed and forcing yourself to do something left-handed, some people can, I can't - and manual shots are all rockets IMO. So this isn't an answer for me.)