For me, the faster response times are vital. The delays in FIFA08 were horrible and contrived.
The problem is passing is now too easy, even on full manual. It's essentially only 8 directional for a start (except whnen it gets scripted to a different direction) and it's far too easy to first-time pass the ball around, even with your back to the receiver.
They need to work on making passing a genuine skill. First time passing should be hard, and virtually impossible for players in weaker teams to achieve, particularly when the player is not facing the receiver.
I'd like to see the ball freed up far more. I want to see far more passes genuinely into space, not scritped to got to the receiver. The whole thing still feels 80% scripted. It's better than PES pure scritped system, but not that much better.
I'll not be impressed if I go San Marino and am first-time passing my way around the pitch.