Just played about 10 games in a row . I could have sworn I was back to playing PES 11!
First off, when holding R2 to defend manually, your player does not intercept balls that are just inches away. Holding R2+A or just holding A fixes that problem, but for people like me who want total control it's quite disappointing.
Loose ball situations need a lot of work; 99.9% of the time even if you get there first, the AI will just clip through you to gain possession.
Also, when defending against the AI, the delay between switching players and gaining control is still too long, resulting in a short pause before they are able to move again.
With all of the improvements made to the AI (increasing difficulty), I had hoped that the CPU would be governed by the same rules as the player (passing accuracy, momentum, reaction time). Unfortunately, I don't think this is the case.
That said, I still enjoy the referees, tackling collision detection and ball physics. I also enjoy the challenge of breaking down a team tactically and figuring out the best way to break through their defense. Scoring in this game feels like an accomplishment and really sucks you in. A little more balance is needed before I fall completely in love.
Edit: Jimmy that strike was perfect! Love the way he wraps his foot around the ball and snaps it outward.