Re: Liverpool Thread(I've Had Enough!!)
Benitez's greatest moments (other than the rather flukey CL final) were in a 3 week span when they beat United 4-1 and Real Madrid similarly. Those are the games held up by Rafites as his 'typical' performances.
I hated watching Liverpool under Benitez. It was safety first, 9 men in your own half hoof the ball at Torres football. The key was that for 1.5 seasons, Torres really was good enough to do it himself. Before and after that period, Rafa's tactics were shown up as too negative to achieve much in the league.
I actually think Pool are playing better now overall than with Rafa. They just can't quite finish chances or be clinical when it matters. A world class striker could make all the difference, but strikers don't tend to do well when they transfer to Liverpool in the last decade (aside, of course, from the aforementioned El Nino).
While I do admit that Dalglish has had us play superbly in the last
season....but this season he has destroyed that by
bringing in his players...and not buying a good finisher.
There was no need to disturb the axis of Lucas-Meireles-Kuyt-Maxi-Suarez.
We had Aquilani, Spearing and Shelvey in midfield as backup...with Gerrard back to fitness.
and voila...he goes and buys Adam, Henderson and Downing....who have added zero value
compared to previous season's midfield....
No need to panic buy Carroll....when we could have waited in the summer and got 2 strikers
for half that price who are better.
But to say that Rafa had us playing with 9 men in our half with
hoofball to Torres.....I think that's a huge exaggeration...
I must say I cannot remember us playing under Rafa
like that at all.....we always passed the ball....and yes we
were defensive against stronger teams away from home...
sure we were not as fluent as Barca....but we did play well...
and the results are there to be seen.
It was Hodgson who had 9 in the half...and played hoofball to Torres.
Even Houllier played a long ball game to Heskey....and was very
defensive...but Houllier was more effective than Hodgson !
So I dont think you are being accurate or fair here.....
Benitez for all his flaws has given Liverpool the most success
in the last 20 years.....he also got his Valencia team to play
pretty well...and they were very effective with decent passing.
You can call Istanbul a fluke....or even beating Real and Man Utd as flukes...
but Rafa firmly established Liverpool in the top-8 teams in Europe
taking them to 2 Finals....1 semi and 1 Q-final of the Champions League...
and top-4 teams in England.......
...something Dalglish is never going to do....nor was Hodgson capable of doing.