Funny how the demo offline was 5 minutes, so most people spent whole month playing online. As far as I remember - most people were very happy with the game back then. Stupid collisions fouls were there, but not as annoying as against AI. I had one of the best games online during the demo phase, on manual (and I can provide screenshots from my games) where I had average of 3 fouls per game. So I cant really see how online players would not want them to work on fouls, which would bring back some excitement and took spamming X pressure away. Its constant defending pressure going unpunished thats killing online gameplay for a lot of people now.
As it is, offline, Im reasonably happy with fouls on user side. Its the AI side that needs work.
You can say all you want about playing certain way, but there are instances, where AI commits clear fouls, barging you off the ball or tripping in the penalty area and nothing is being given, or its a free kick foe AI. This you cant argue with. there is more than enough examples online.
I'm not sure if you misunderstood my post but I'm not arguing there isn't problems online (god knows there is) I was referring to the fact that we who play online often get that we only want to play a end to end goal scoring ping pong fest. Something I think in general isn't true, but the game force you to play in certain way if you want to compete with others.
I can't get any enjoyment from offline since I find it stale and boring (and I have FM for a more RPG- experience or what you might call it) and the same goes for the friendly lobby since there isn't anything at stake. It might sound childish but even if it's just some virtual points thats doesn't mean anything it adds something for me. I'm the same IRL, I HATE when a friend just wants to play some tennis just for fun and doesn't want to make a match of it.
But as you mentioned the demo did get A LOT of praise among online players, even on PA1, so I think a lot of people would love a more realistic gameplay online if they only would get the chance...