For those who somewhat lost the joy of scoring the following
might reingnite it a bit, as it did for me.
1. Put shooting on manual.
2. Only perform R2 shots.
Bonus: Disable the power bar. Havent tried this myself yet but
someone @Emroth suggested this in a previous post
(sorry, forgot your username).
As you know, R2 gives you the most control over direction and effect of your attempt. Now, in my experience, when you force yourself to always make that extra effort to push R2 first, you either have to up your reaction speed or create some space for yourself. This makes shooting more of an 'event' so to say. Add to that the extra control and imho somewhat better animations and shooting could become a more enjoyable and surprising experience for you.
Sure enough, the effect might wear off after some time but when i am so used to 'always' using R2 that it goes automatically, i might just disable the power meter to artificially make it more challenging again.
Here's an example of an R2 shot:
So i am pretty sure the exact same shot without R2 would of gone much more towards the middle of the goal, within reach of the keeper. The R2 shot however was a much better translation of the shot i wanted to perform and as i for once didnt failed with my input here the output felt really satisfying.
Ofcourse, this is only logical, thats what a control shot is intended for, but somehow i never used it that much, just tried it occasionally. Perhaps because i was somewhat biased towards it, i considered it a bit of a 'cheat' to be able to press a button and your shot somehow becomes more dangerous.
Now i realize i might have been too harsh and maybe i should look at it the other way around. On manual at least, square is the equivalent of closing your eyes and hope for the best whereas most real-life shots are placed, eyes wide open R2 shots.
At least for now i dont feel R2 is magically doing things in 2020, it just translates my input better with the only tradeoff being my shots having less power (which in my eyes is only a good thing). I guess with R2 manual shots are much more similar to manual passes.
PS Above clip is on long grass and like i said in my previous comment, i think you can notice the effect on the ball. For example, the short pass at 0:26 almost comes to a dead stop.