I really don't understand the disappointment
I really don't understand people who actually get excited when they change the menus, the absolute least most important part of the game (they need to function, that's all) - and yet, they advertise it as their #2 Master League "new feature" and apparently there are actually people out there who think that's great news:
If I think of the things that annoyed me the most about vanilla PES this year it would be [...] the awful UI
I don't understand that. But you are entitled to that opinion, as is every gameplay pessimist because passes are still perfectly struck rockets that doesn't represent reality etc. etc. etc. etc. - even if we don't understand each other.
What makes no sense is bringing up the other game's conference and saying "well at least it's better than that shite".
So what if it is? That makes it okay because it's the only choice we have? We laugh when they implement career mode cutscenes that everybody in the world just skips now because they're so pointless, but we're excited for the Konami version. It's just fanboyism, or at the very least, putting on rose-tinted spectacles and not realising how hypocritical we are.
Also, I mean:
After the PES video I watched the Fifa gameplay changes breakdown, and the very first one the man says is "we've really focused on toning down the defending to create more exciting 1vs1 situations this year".... ummm.... what? Really? I don't know about you, but I'd take having to see the same PES animations and physics over stupid gameplay changes any day of the week.
We're decrying them now for talking about gameplay and making an effort to change it (even if misguided)? As opposed to Konami showing something that looks identical to PES 2019 and supposedly demonstrating the new "revolutionary" gameplay features, yet we can't tell if they're even there or not?
Which, by the way, will probably be the case with the other game, and there's no gameplay footage yet for that reason I'd bet - but there are so many basic gameplay issues, stiffness and just ping-pong craziness with PES that yes, I am disappointed to see that the core of the game is identical again this year, and PES is the focus here, not what the other game does or doesn't achieve.
(This is me trying to explain myself to all the guys who "don't understand" why some of us are so pessimistic, by the way - not meaning to come across in a bullish fashion. I'm just trying to get across that, hey, "what do you expect" is a really lame attitude and the game has been stagnant since PES 2017.)
For balance... It's always about "feel" with PES, and it may well feel much better in our hands. The AI may be better and it may stop Bournemouth playing like Barcelona. I doubt it, HIGHLY doubt it (especially because they're not talking about that), but it might.
But I can factually see my personal bugbears of 2019, nearly all gameplay related, are still there from the video (e.g. the player having the ball at their feet but taking five steps after you press an action button - the power bar appears - to actually hit the ball, by which time the opponent has won it off you, for no reason other than to give the defender a chance).