Should I make a FIFA video showing the annoyances of FIFA? The lack of control etc? Also them god awful player models and Pathetic appearances? I agree PES has always had those type of problems and I for one have constantly ranted about them for a long time but for me the Game is still 10 times more playable than FIFA.
Sadly I don't want a game, I want a simulation, and in that sense there is such a thing as too much playability and response.
FIFA needs to change some tactical/AI things to be alot more like PES where you have instant in-game recall of different formations (so you can change from a 4-4-2 to a 2-5-3 formation if you want to), attack mentality of the team etc.
Playing FIFA08 on the PC, it gets frustrating when playing with Barca, and although you might be trailing 1-0, your players refuse to push up beyond the mid line. The CPU team always have 4 back players unpressured to relieve the pressure on, and even though you might push 2 attackers up on them, as soon as you "let go" of them, they just trail back home.
BUT, that is last-gen where you don't have any editing of formations and such in-game (besides rudimentary changing of 4-4-2, 4-3-3 etc. But no way of making everyone push up like crazy, or such.
I haven't played Next-Gen in Manager or such where I have sat and played around with formations and such, but I do believe you can edit positions of players, and such, and attack arrows etc like in PES.
Also, FIFA has a "Cancel" (RT and LT I think) but this could do with being "Super" aswell so that you can take control and intercept passes early if you notice it going too long etc.
Still, their gameplay is very nice right now, so they can focus on the abstract programming of making the players behave more like humans.