andish2001
Championship
- 1 May 2005
After receiving the RROD yesterday for the first time in 1 and a half years, i have sent my 360 to microsoft and after seeing the videos of euro 2008 was in the mood for some football gaming. So i plugged in the PS2 on my 42 inch plasma (lol) and stuck pes4 in (the best version in my eyes).
And what a revelation. Yeah i know its a little rough around the edges, theres a serious lack of defender AI at times and its old and unlicensed, but its just amazing. I remember why I fell in love with PES.
Everything about it just...works. People say you cant feel differences with players in FIFA, and I now see what they mean. It isnt necessarily that martins can outrun defenders on pes and not on fifa, but even the way they run. Play with england and you'll quickly notice that beckham strides along effortlessly with grace, whereas gerrard, while still effective, is much more leggy and slightly more difficult to control. Its a subtle difference, but its impact is huge. All the things i miss from pes quickly became apparent:
- proper goalmouth scrambles
- incredible set pieces. defenders actually come up and start their runs AS the kicker takes it, compared to fifa where they run around randomly during the entire sequence. Whipping in a ball from the right with Beckham (and his perfectly matching animation which looks shite on fifa) towards a flying Campbell and Terry (old rosters) is immensely satisfying. It is surprising to me that this area has never received the attention it needs in FIFA.
- backspin long shots that rise the way seedorf's or edman's (earlier in this thread) do rather than random looping reverse shots with a dumbass goalkeeper.
- keep in mind im playing a patched version, but something about the crowd is just so much more involving and at times, exhilarating compared to fifa. They cheer more loudly and scoring a goal is SO much more satisfying in this version of the game.
- best point of all : NO CHESTING. the players jump and kick the ball or if they cant reach it, header it. Thats the way it should be.
I could go on for hours, but after thinking of what is BETTER in this "next generation" version of fifa compared to "old gen" PES4, I could only come up with a few things:
- the finesse shot changed football gaming. I continually find myself trying it on PES4 just for the hell of it. A great addition.
- the trick stick and the freedom it brings. Tricks are pathetic on PES.
- the AI at TIMES. Not always. Attacking-wise I still believe old PES has the advantage.
My point being that in all the hubbub of night lighting, incredible graphics (which fifa does have) and perfect licensing or player representation, i think both konami AND ea have forgotten what makes a good football game. Dont get me wrong - FIFA 08 is definately a better game than pes2008, but i cant see myself playing it with the massive smile on my face i get when something realistic happens in pes until they add that sort of 'freedom', despite being on rails AND being limited by a small number of animations, that PES has. Its incredibly hard to explain why it feels so good. I guess...the best way to describe it is to watch pizarro's goal against real madrid recently...THAT is what happens in pes and cannot happen in fifa. Even in the game i just played, i cut the ball back to rooney and in the heat of the moment he hit it, but it was a bump ball, although still forced a great save. It was a mistake, but inherent mistakes (or more the possibility of inherent mistakes) in football are what makes it so great.
Please note: I havent owned a PES since pes5 and have owned every fifa on 360 since 07, including ucl, and play them all the time.
And what a revelation. Yeah i know its a little rough around the edges, theres a serious lack of defender AI at times and its old and unlicensed, but its just amazing. I remember why I fell in love with PES.
Everything about it just...works. People say you cant feel differences with players in FIFA, and I now see what they mean. It isnt necessarily that martins can outrun defenders on pes and not on fifa, but even the way they run. Play with england and you'll quickly notice that beckham strides along effortlessly with grace, whereas gerrard, while still effective, is much more leggy and slightly more difficult to control. Its a subtle difference, but its impact is huge. All the things i miss from pes quickly became apparent:
- proper goalmouth scrambles
- incredible set pieces. defenders actually come up and start their runs AS the kicker takes it, compared to fifa where they run around randomly during the entire sequence. Whipping in a ball from the right with Beckham (and his perfectly matching animation which looks shite on fifa) towards a flying Campbell and Terry (old rosters) is immensely satisfying. It is surprising to me that this area has never received the attention it needs in FIFA.
- backspin long shots that rise the way seedorf's or edman's (earlier in this thread) do rather than random looping reverse shots with a dumbass goalkeeper.
- keep in mind im playing a patched version, but something about the crowd is just so much more involving and at times, exhilarating compared to fifa. They cheer more loudly and scoring a goal is SO much more satisfying in this version of the game.
- best point of all : NO CHESTING. the players jump and kick the ball or if they cant reach it, header it. Thats the way it should be.
I could go on for hours, but after thinking of what is BETTER in this "next generation" version of fifa compared to "old gen" PES4, I could only come up with a few things:
- the finesse shot changed football gaming. I continually find myself trying it on PES4 just for the hell of it. A great addition.
- the trick stick and the freedom it brings. Tricks are pathetic on PES.
- the AI at TIMES. Not always. Attacking-wise I still believe old PES has the advantage.
My point being that in all the hubbub of night lighting, incredible graphics (which fifa does have) and perfect licensing or player representation, i think both konami AND ea have forgotten what makes a good football game. Dont get me wrong - FIFA 08 is definately a better game than pes2008, but i cant see myself playing it with the massive smile on my face i get when something realistic happens in pes until they add that sort of 'freedom', despite being on rails AND being limited by a small number of animations, that PES has. Its incredibly hard to explain why it feels so good. I guess...the best way to describe it is to watch pizarro's goal against real madrid recently...THAT is what happens in pes and cannot happen in fifa. Even in the game i just played, i cut the ball back to rooney and in the heat of the moment he hit it, but it was a bump ball, although still forced a great save. It was a mistake, but inherent mistakes (or more the possibility of inherent mistakes) in football are what makes it so great.
Please note: I havent owned a PES since pes5 and have owned every fifa on 360 since 07, including ucl, and play them all the time.