I honestly feel Pes 2016 is the most complex futebol game to date, especially in comparison to earlier Pes games. The AI is far more advanced and the freedom of play and variation in games is alot better.
- Pes 2012 is good for what it is, but freedom of play is not that great, feels verey restricted with dribbling.
- Pes 2013 good again , I dont like the balloony ball physics and the way the ball feels like it is attached to a spring.
- Pes 2014 not bad, but the variation and freedom is the worst here, I found this game very repetitive. Not to mention how players who should be faster just get overtaken by slow defenders.
- Pes 2015, well just a not as good version of Pes 2016.
Im playing superstar difficulty, and at this difficulty it is the hardest Pes by quite a margin. Im guessing thats why many folks dont like it, as it requires you to be alot better than earlier Pes games. Ive had to improve so much to be able to consistently play well against better teams, even lower teams can surprise with their 'different' game plan.
Took me so long to find a formation and settings for my team that suit my playstyle, this is another factor that hugely influences the quality of games.