Yeh I prefer manual shooting on 2014 too. But not with the arrows otherwise I feel like I'm cheating. It's definitely not as over powered as 2015 and 2016.
Do you remember the old PES celebration when the player would start kicking his legs out and then start gyrating? It went on for about 5 mins

When I first saw that I completely lost it because I knew nothing about viewing the different celebrations in edit mode.
On the new ones I hate the one where the player just runs along the crowd with his arms out giving it attitude
I'm loving 2014 at the moment. I'm finding it so much better than 2016 and also 2015. The shots are not as overpowered, and there is a kind of randomness about the game. For example you get more deflections on shots and passes. And there are free kicks, yes it's great! There was one game I played, I was controlling Wright-Phillips, and there was a 50-50 ball Wrighty running along the touch line and the CPU player running from midfield trying to get there first. I knew Wrighty had more pace and I could see the out come. It was a Cameroon v Caniggia type tackle (90 World Cup) and I got the free kick. Only a small thing but it gave me joy to see that happen. In the newer ones the ref would probably play on.
At the moment it's feeling like a PS3 version of PES5.
I was reading the 2014 tactics thread Klashman and want to thank you for the info.