I post it here as well. The Russian guys are collecting feed-back which will be, than forwarded to Konami via WENB (where I happen to be banned).
http://forums.evo-web.co.uk/showthread.php?p=3069340#post3069340
My demo feedback:
I think the game is enjoyable but it has as every game flaws, which in my opinion can be addressed.
Based on roughly 10 hours of playing on PS4 / superstar, full manual
Top priority:
1. keepers inside box reactions
2. referees - fouls
3. shooting variety
1. goalkeepers
Although they are making amazing saves and re-action saves, they have quite a few problems.
in certain situations when an attacker is carrying the ball inside the box, they simply stuck to their lines or come out late to cover the corners of the goal. This is not helped by the fact, that when they decide to dive, they make an unnecessary mini jump before jumping and dive late and slow-motion, with not fully stretched arms.
This kills the joy of scoring. Too accurate shooting is not helping either.
Example video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sAbG3VZiwgE
2. referees
They are bad, inconsistent. I think there are enough fouls, but they are not given. Last men tackles not awarded with red, etc.
Advantage rule is ridiculous. Almost every time advantage is given. Should be only in case of real goal scoring opportunity.
3. shooting
It's not varied enough. Almost every shot is on goal. Lack of AI. high shots, over the bar shots.
R2 shooting can be overpowered, but I think the keepers should be improved.
Not real difference between players. Almost every player can pull of really strong, long range shots.
You cannot modify the shot type after you pressed square. I mean start with a normal shot and changing your mind and press R2 afterwards. It was in PES5-6 and was a really good weapon to trick defenders and keepers.
4. defending
I find the sliding tackles too easy to pull of. They lack variety and every player skills seems to be the same.
5. general
Bug. There are 2 nets shapes, they start with tighter version, once they are connected they become loose and remain loose.
Not every dive should be awarded with yellow card (If you fall to the ground without being a player near you, or if it shouldn't be obvious for the referee it shouldn't be awarded with a yellow card).
When a ball is out and it's obvious who contacted the ball last, that team's players shouldn't gesticulate in a crazy way, claiming that they have the throw in.
individuality should be improved, difference between players.
Night lighting could be further improved.
Replays should be re-designed. Too slow motion.
6. Further areas for improvement
Bring that fucking coin toss back
Implement a sliding tackle system which requires skill, where direction can be influenced, speed, length of sliding, etc..
Enable to record voice to replays (not high priority on PS4 - it's recorded anyway).
Smaller stadiums for master league.
This what came to my mind this evening.