Nobody will make a slightly just slightly realistic football game, not even 2K.The resources(time/money) involved in creating a simulator game would only be justified by something like 15-20 million copies sold in one year. Also the market for hardcore simulator games is just a niche...
You're perfectly right, this version will probably satisfy a lot of peoples needs. . . . I just felt that they were nearly there with Pes 14 and would have tweaked it properly this year .. .. ..but money talks at the end of the day.