Maybe I'd see some long shots go in if I drop down from Superstar, but then there's the trade-off that the game won't be as difficult. But I just tried practising shooting in training mode, not a single shot from outside the box went in. I hit numerous shots that were fast, accurate, and right into the top corner. Every time the keeper just plucked it out of the air.
That's the problem right there. I had a nice couple of games tonight playing as Schalke, they played great in general and rather than trying to score regular goals, I was hitting shots from different distances and positions but none of them even came close to going in, even though a lot of them were pretty accurate and had pace on them.