By depth I mean, the world around football manager and how transfers and how things are very similarly if not identically structured to that of the real world. PES doesn't do that in ML, they could easily just give us more leagues for a lot of that depth. They should have a loyalty stat or something, I have seen Puyol with Madrid countless times. They should have a better youth system. Internationals should either be competitive or friendlies. So that if it's a friendly you can pull your player out of it. Player roles, so if you sign a player as a backup or rotation player, he won't complain when you are barely playing him. It's really not that hard.
I think Konami are undecided whether they want full realism in their ML or some of that old school fantasy ML. I really don't mind whichever side they take, but make a decision and run with it. FIFA are running with their idea, while it has bugs, its very playable. Too bad the gameplay is not what it should be. To me local multiplayer and Manager modes are the two most important reasons to buy a football games, and neither game cuts it sadly. Telling me not to play it, sounds like a fanboy answer to a justified complain. If you don't like much of the business side, I am sure they could just do what they did this year with adding the "board control" or whatever that was and actually make it mean something. So if you untick the "board control" you don't worry about business. So say you want a forward, you tell the board and they deal with it and bring in what they can. You tell the board whose expiring contracts you'd like to renew. They'll deal with the negotiations. For some of us the business is fun, and would love to have it so we tick on "board control" or whatever you want to call it. Surely Konami should add that.
PS
Other things they should add if Konami decides to go the realistic route:
- There are no national supercup.
- There are no games during the winter transfer window.
- In cups like the English one where it's only one leg win or go home, the games are played in a random stadium instead of the home teams stadium. It just takes away from the immersion.
- More divisions!!!(I'd love to take Sant Andreu from the Spanish 3rd tier to Primera and maybe some CL action)
- A more intelligent version of training, I don't know how, but come up with something.
- Loan deals IRL to be represented in the start of the game. It just takes away from the experience when Sergio Canales stays in Valencia w/o any negotiations.
- Player contracts to mirror those of real life. Hector Moreno's contract with Espanyol ends in the very first season, despite him just arriving there in real life.
- Being able to renew contracts at any point. Not just 6 months before it expires during the transfer period.
- Make the negotiations more direct. That whole sending the scout to negotiate first is dull. Let us send what we feel is an acceptable offer. I really like what FIFA have done in regards of transfer negotiations. Konami should take note.
While somethings are bells and whistles, they add to the experience, and PES to me is ML and Local multiplayer. If either of those don't fulfill my expectations, I feel robbed of my money. Local Multiplayer is fun this year, but ML is not. So I feel that Konami owe me $20. :p