I was having a pretty bad time with this demo to begin with. Most of the flaws in Demo 1 had been addressed (not necessarily fixed, but improved), apart from the way the game gets stupidly frantic when the speed of play rises slightly... but it just felt a bit chaotic to me, both attacking and defending a bit random. As did results: first game I won 3-0, cpu had 1 shot on goal (off target). Went off for something to eat, came back and lost three games on the trot. Passes constantly went ahead of or behind the intended player, couldn't get the weighting right at all. Really infuriating, because in PES2011 passing was my main strength - I'd developed the Barca/Villarreal/Arsenal style to the point where I'd massively dominate possession in pretty much every game, even ones I lost. Suddenly I could barely find the target with a 10 yard pass. Long passages of play that just looked like kids running around the playground. Grim.
Enjoying it more now, and the main thing that's improved the game for me has been changing the pass assistance from 2 to 0 bars. I thought I'd try it out to see just how much harder it was to control the passing (people like Jimmy and Zee, who I play fairly regularly, have been using 0 or 1 so I didn't want to get left behind). I'd expected it to be much harder - to my surprise it was much easier, at least for me. The weighting now seems more like PES2011, and even though you have to be more precise with aiming - which is good, because it allows more freedom with more ambitious passes - I've stopped putting the ball ahead of/behind my players, and have been getting it to feet pretty consistently. Very odd. Don't understand this, but I'm not complaining.
Shooting seems even easier than before, in a way - yes the goalies have been improved (still nowhere near good enough, but improved), but instead of seeing shots sail slowly into the middle of the goal with the keeper flapping, I'm now seeing shots go much faster and more into the corners, without being aimed any more carefully than before. So it's still too easy to score from 20 yards, it's just that the goal which ensues looks less stupid than it would have done in Demo 1. Progress of a sort, I suppose. It seems that shot accuracy been boosted massively to balance the improved goalies, but then in turn it seems that shot blocking has also been boosted massively to balance the increased shot accuracy. Seems to have changed the whole feel of the game in attack.
Overall, that's probably an improvement over Demo 1 (albeit a quick and dirty fix), because the scores seem lower overall, and there are fewer silly 4-4 draws. Not every change is an improvement though. The speed has definitely gone up even further: in Demo 1 it was at least possible to slow the game right down, but now, perhaps because of the increased pressure, it seems to be more frantic all the time. The jerkiness of the animations is even worse than in the first demo - watching the highlights at half time, you can see all the players jittering slightly as they move in a straight line, and it really does look terrible. Turning is still too fast, and acceleration in tight spaces from a standing start is still too pronounced - and now we've got blokes like Robben, Lennon, Eto'o and Bale in this demo we can see all too clearly how bad that looks with players who are already really, really fast and/or agile. Christ knows what Messi or Ronaldo will look like in the full game. Not realistic, that's for sure.
Crossing is much easier, which again is good and bad. On the one hand, players running in to connect with a cross no longer sprint past the ball and end up in the net; on the other, we seem to be getting laser-guided crosses every time, while it's still quite hard to position the defender correctly (momentum taking him off-track too often), in multiplayer at least. Could see far too many easy goals from crosses once online is up and running.
Couple more obvious issues: when you're not in possession of the ball, your player's speed means nothing. Maicon was running down the wing, I got control of Bale and set off after him. Maicon (with the ball) stayed ahead of Bale (sprinting full-on without the ball) for about 40 yards. It's like the catch-up problem from 2011 in reverse. This is really, really bad. Also, I'm starting to think that this right-stick thing, where you select players to aim for at set pieces, is useless. Even top free kick takers don't seem to understand that they should be putting the ball slightly in front of the man at a corner, so he can make a run and attack the ball. They seem to either aim for his head where he's standing (which only works for Peter Crouch), or else just hoof it in his vague direction - and by the time the X appears on the ground to show where the ball's going, it's usually wrong, and if you've started running the player already, his momentum means he can't change direction in time. Alternatively, if you don't make the run until the X appears, it's too late to actually reach the ball. Whereas when I tried corners the old way (into the mixer with R2 and swerve) I had a lot more success, the computer selecting an appropriate player and allowing me to attack the ball properly. Done that way, corners are in fact much nicer than in 2011, but it seems a bit of a missed opportunity.
Don't know if it's just me, but the "active AI" seems a bit less pronounced, too. It's all very nice in midfield, but when you get into the final third (or when you're trying to break) you still get the same problem as before: you're there with the ball, three players ahead of you, and they're just standing there like idiots, being marked and offering barely any movement at all. Occasionally you see someone moving, and can hit them with the pass, but more often in the last third it's the same frustration as in PES2011. What happened to the diagonal runs, dummy runs, all that stuff we were promised in those super-duper preview vids? Konami went out of their way to boast about these, making individual videos to illustrate them in mouth-watering detail... and they're not there. What the fuck?
Basically Demo 2 seems more like PES2011 in every way. In some areas that's not a bad thing, in others it is. Not sure about this game yet, even though there's clearly something fantastic in there somewhere. Will persevere.