1. Has anyone else tried the penalty system? I had two pads connected tonight, using the second one to hack down players in the box, so I could try a few pens - I haven't been given one in a game yet.
And wouldn't you just know it. Yet again something's been dumbed down (rather than properly explained by Konami) because people who didn't understand it claimed it was "broken". Sure the PES2011 penalty system wasn't so great in its execution, but it was a good skill-based system which made sense, and it needed refining not ditching.
Well it's been ditched, and unless I'm mistaken, the new system really is broken. It just seems to have gone back to PS2 days - aim and shoot, nothing else - but much much dumber, because get this: I'm not sure it's actually possible to miss. I mean literally. I took 5 penalties with Hulk, and I was deliberately trying to shoot high and wide with the last three. No luck! I mean, you max out the power gauge, push the stick as far as it'll go and hold it there... sure recipe for a Waddle-in-Italia-90-style disaster, right? Um, no. It gives you a very powerful and (presumably unsaveable) shot into the very top corner.
Seriously, that bad. I hope I'm wrong (I couldn't be arsed to do more than 5 because it's actually not that easy to walk the ball into the box with one pad and then foul that player with the other). But if it really is this bad, and you can hit an unstoppable penalty every time by doing what is technically the easiest (and logically the worst) thing you could possibly do in a penalty situation, that does raise the prospect of some interesting penalty shoot-outs online. The game goes to penalties at 10pm; both players are still there at 4am, wondering which one will be first to crack and just switch off the PS3 and go to bed.
2. Anyone else as worried as me that the specific reason why goalkeepers are so bad seems ominously unfixable at short notice? I.e. the fact that they dive from a standing start every time - they have no animation for a side-step shuffle across the box, so every dive is like a lamppost toppling over and as a result they can never reach the corners. I mean, it's not just that their reaction times need to be patched (although they do, they really really do). It's that their whole system is wrong. Their behaviour needs to change completely, and you need a bunch of new animations there - and this needs to be balanced against the shooting. How much better are they going to get? Jon Murphy keeps saying they're the priority, understandably, but are they going to be able to stick in a totally new goalkeeper system in a few weeks, when this was the best they could do after a year?
The smart money could be on bizarre "leap tall buildings in a single bound"-type dives (from a standing start) once final code rolls around. God I hope not. Still, it'd be better than this.
3. I had the ball on the left wing, in my own half, with Ashley Young. I hit a 12-yard pass infield to Park Ji-Sung. Put down the pad, went into the kitchen, put the kettle on, walked around the kitchen whistling until it had boiled, poured it into the teacup, stirred, scratched my head, waited a few minutes for it to brew, added the milk, had a sip, walked back into the front room and picked up the pad - just in time for Park to receive the ball.
4. It's a good game though. Weirdly, the more I play, the less extreme the speed seems. It's still way too fast at times, and the movement of the players when dribbling and turning is way WAY too fast (emphasised by the unbelievably slow pace of the ball in flight or across the ground), but at other times the game speed drops, sometimes even to a pleasing crawl. At which point you can really see all the good things in here, which I hope will be brought out in the second demo and the finished game. It's already good, and more fun overall than PES2011 (which was starting to look very rusty indeed, even before this demo came out), but it could still be really, REALLY good, if everything ends up coming together. But I'm not what you'd call a born optimist. Very much hoping to be pleasantly surprised.