Re: PES 2009 News, Discussion and Rumours
I'm still playing FIFA 08 - eleven months after release - just as much as day one. It's the first FIFA game to hold my attention for that long, in the same way PES used to.
So, I think we are entitled to be confident that FIFA 09 will keep us hooked for the long haul.
Exactly why I'm hopeful for FIFA 09.
I still play FIFA 08 and think "Christ the reaction times are awful, in PES I would have backheeled that pass straight away and created an opportunity but in this he just runs straight into the defender like a MONG ARRRGGGH" etc... I play PES2008 on the PSP and put some passing moves together which aren't possible in real-time playing FIFA (you have to press to do the action half-an-hour early).
But all it takes to make me happy with FIFA 09 is better response times and human goalkeepers (and the AI but we've already heard from people playtesting the game in Leipzig that the AI is the same

). For me, the rest is perfect, from the physics, to the fully manual controls, to the game modes (lower league teams so I don't have to play as Liverpool all the time, a realistic management career mode, a realistic "Be A Pro" career mode, online "Be A Pro" 5v5/10v10 play, but most importantly,
online leagues - something I wrote a letter to Konami about, begging them to include, five years ago ... I HATE ranked matches, playing random friendlies over and over and over).
Now it may well turn out that the goalkeepers are the same as before, in which case it will be a huge disappointment. The videos would suggest otherwise but we don't know without playing it, especially those of us who use lower-league teams (there was never going to be a FIFA 09 video featuring teams outside of the Premier League, God forbid :roll

.
But I've been bored of the base-PES engine since the early PS2 days, simply because it's not been rewritten from scratch for the CPU power on the PS2, LET ALONE the PS3, which is criminal. So that means the same AI, the same AI cheating, the same repetitive scripts, the same "on-rails" players, the same "on-rails" ball movement, the same automaticness about everything you do (with the game deciding whether to be kind and let your pass get through or your shot go in, rather than your skill at playing the game, which gets to the point where I think "I might as well let the CPU play the CPU because if I've got no control in crucial moments I might as well have no control at all) and even the same Master League (which bears no resemblence to real life, IMO). All from the PSX era.
This is outweighed for some people by the good points, such as the old reviewer's golden comment when it comes to PES, "you never see the same goal twice" - which is absolutely right, very satisfying, and the reason why I still play PES2008 on the PSP.
So I can totally 100% understand why people still play PES. It's not the "absolute worst football series in the world ever omfg" that some people make it out to be. But as far as I'm concerned, the PSP is where it belongs and where it plays best, because it's simplified, ten-year-old (or "tried and tested" depending on your viewpoint) gameplay. That doesn't mean it's an awful game.