Something about 17's on-the-ball gameplay just feels off to me. It feels like it's stuck half-way between FIFA 16's "weight" and modern FIFA's "completely free movement, light-as-a-feather" - but not in a good way. Almost in a "glitchy" way, but I don't know how to explain it properly.
Sometimes I will try to move my player with a defender on my shoulder, and it's like I'm stuck in tar. Sometimes I'll be dribbling and the responsiveness of the body movement isn't enough to beat a man when it should be given the player I'm using. It feels like I'm fighting the controller a little bit, I don't know.
It's the FIFA game I think I've spent most time on by far - I loved my career mode save, because it's the FIFA with the biggest difference between good/bad teams* (which is really satisfying, beating poor teams 5-0 but getting beat by the big boys, instead of every game having a similar scoreline).
But yeah, it doesn't feel great going back to it now, for some reason.
*Excluding FIFA World Cup 2010, which I played again the other day and oh my God. I'd forgotten what that could do. Playing on Legendary I was beating teams like San Marino easily, but France destroyed me 5-0 and I was laughing as they did it. Still a fantastic game.