Very early impressions of 17 are quite good. I'm using
@Topaz great mod in combination with Matt's sliders and a speed hack value of .94 just to slow down the animations and make things a little more weighty.
In terms of Frostbite, it seems to be less 'Skatey' than more recent versions, the inertia of the players is better too (but not on FIFA 16's level). The Shooting seems a little inconsistent, but maybe I'm just not very good at it yet. The physical elements of Ignite/16 is a big miss, but it's definitely been fun to play, and playing a Frostbite FIFA without 1v1 and with a solid AI is in itself a massive positive. I still need to play more to conclude.
It's a shame there's no comprehensive patches for it, as it's clearly better than 21 and would be a good option if it had the faces, etc.