I have done the same. From 16 all the way to 20. My favorite is 17 by a long mile. There are fouls, dribbling works, headers are not nerfed. Only con so far is the size of the ball but that can be overlooked. Why did I stop playing this and bought 18, 19 and 20 only to come back to it?Being at home has made me download all the old FIFAs again, and 17 was always my favourite. Have to say, I was a bit annoyed at the responsiveness of 17 today, so reinstalled 18 and was really pleasantly surprised when playing the World Cup mode. The AI was ridiculously deadly with their finishing, but. May have to give a World Cup a go.
I'm on pc and I wish more modders supported it.