Got home from work and played for an hour or so. The AI's dribbling is truly FIFA/EASFC style, and trying to defend is just a waste of time. When the AI have the ball in your half, it's like they're a team of prime Raheem Sterlings and my team become a team of Mr. Blobbys.
Ball physics are worse, I think - there's just no such thing as a loose ball, exactly like FIFA/EASFC. Passes either go directly to your target, or directly to the opponent, with nothing in-between. And the deflections are the same, which can be absolutely hilarious - twice in one match, a ball cannoned off my player's arse and magically landed at the waiting instep of a midfielder.
For me, they're clearly aiming for the same market as EA - to the point that they're even enacting EA's feedback (e.g. "I should never lose possession if I successfully tackle someone because that's totally unfair and unfun or some shit").
Maybe it would be better on Top Player rather than Superstar, but 1) guess what, that's not allowed for some reason (?!) and 2) that won't fix the physics from being horrendously, mobile-game basic.