I still don't buy it. It's clear that it hasn't changed.
All the things that are being worked on for release: goalkeepers, shooting, pass assistance, crossing, chipped through balls, animation transitions, even defensive AI positioning, do not include the balance between direct dribbling and defending.
Unfortunately the more and more I play the 1st demo the realization comes to me that the mindset of the game, regardless of later code, is unfairly skewered to the attackers. Unlike PES 2010 and 2011 this is not even a case of “learning the art of defending” or not “over pressuring”, the game is BUILT THIS WAY.
Dribbling > defending. That's the way it is.
That is the PES 6 style direction they have gone with the game. You can understand the technically accomplished players being hard to defend against, but it is the average players and technically limited players as well that have received a universal boost in dribble accuracy and speed. The differences aren't great enough.
For example in PES 2011 I felt clear differences between the likes of Luca Toni and Krasic. With Toni I had to use his strength to hold the ball up and lay it off, also taking advantage of his height to win headers, he was a slow player and a clumsy dribbler who took heavy touches. With Krasic I could go directly at defenders with little fear because he is clearly an amazing dribbler, the ball could stick to his feet as I've seen it do in real life. But here it is far too easy to skip past defenders in 1-on-1s for MOST PLAYERS, and it is deliberately done to encourage attacking play.
The balance is spoiled. Silky attacking play that puts the defenders on the back foot as second-class-citizens has been favoured, rather than a balanced model that gives fairness to the attackers and defenders, in order to rely on skill.
R2+X hold up play is random and skilless imo. Timing your challenges depends on luck rather than patience and finesse, which is a shame because you could really LEARN how to defend well in PES 2010 and 2011.
Granted, there are elements of luck and randomness in real football too, but 'form is temporary, class is permanent', and skill usually shows itself in most situations. But how can I use skill in defending when I do not even feel fully in control of my defensive players! They feel too loose and too susceptible to being wrong footed. The slightest millimeter and you lose the 1 on 1. Its like it is black and white, and real defending is not like that, unless you're facing the very very best dribblers like Messi/Ronaldo. But not everyone is supposed to be like Messi/Ronaldo. This is the downside that happens when you go to the other extreme end of responsivity, the floatiness and skating around, the reduced solid weighty feeling of players that is detrimental to defending.
Online is going to be dreadful. Just you wait until the novelty of the AI and responsivity has worn off. It'll be PES 6 all over again
While I still look forward to having fun with the game, and it has taken leaps forward with the AI and plenty of other things, its positives have been diminished and outweighed by this problem. Sorry, but my enthusiasm has dimmed.