Every-time i talk tennis game someone came and talk about about Tennis Elbow lol. I found it cool but not fun, and as a complete game > i place the two others above as a complete games. Just my own feeling, but i'm quickly bored with Tennis Elbow.
They're more fun to play, and got a soul let's say, overall. Final Match Tennis and Super Tennis got also more ball directions, but not power, feeling, curve etc. as the other. Yes ball placement is very very important, but ball reaction/physics is too, people seems to forget about it.
What i don't like in tennis Elbow 2013 and + is that they've added so much stuff on a very basic engine that you can feel it to the heart: a good game, but too, too much stretched in every part if you know what i mean. I can feel it and don't like it that much.
BUT it's my own feeling, my personnal opinion. I'm not alone thinkin that, many place Tennis Elbow 3rd etc.
As a complete package, fun and physics i prefers the two others.
AO Tennis is apart, let's say that it's missing fun too. And i don't understand how much there's assistances in the vanilla game : desactivated it's ain't more complicated than Top Spin... Just the fact that you play online against people with everything activated disgust me : even the player positionning. You can pose your gamepad on the table practically lol.
Never tried the 2 btw, but i will probably took the AO 3. But tests and everything says all that for the moment, even that one doesn't reach Top Spin overall as a complete tennis game.
The issue is that i discovered the game when it was bad too, before tons of updates which completely changed the game. But it's not in terms of "complete + fun" on Top Spin level.
VT2 is pretty different in terms of feeling so hard to compare, but you can compare AO with TS4.
I think it's more the guys from AO or even the World tour Tennis (bad game but with a good ambiance/presentation and the rest + and some idea) who probably needs the guy(s) from Tennis Elbow. 2K Czech is kinda dead, the producers have stopped a long time ago... Due to the awful Gran Slam Tennis which took all the licences / EA style.