strikeforce? what strikeforce? Van Persie? he had only 2 good seasons in the PL even Berba can beat him in stats and i only talk about the time he spent in Manchester. overall those 10 RVP goals per season are not an insurance, lets face it v. Nistelrooy was the last real striker in United. in the past years Ronaldo was the real deal up front. so i wont rely on RVP since he can pick up injuries very easy and and since Chicarito and probably Welbeck will be gone.
I like Berbatov very much, but since you are talking about him beating van Persie in stats I had my doubts so I have double checked it.
RVP beats Berbatov in stats, clearly!!!
Of course RVN was a great striker, but I would prefer players like C.Ronaldo, RVP or Rooney instead, because the do not only score a lot, but also assist a lot. Here are the scoring stats in PL of some strikers that also played for ManU.
To compare I have just taken their last 5 years in PL:
van Nistelrooy:
05/06 >> 35 matches >> 21 goals + 3 assists
04/04 >> 17 matches >> 6 goals + 1 assist
03/04 >> 32 matches >> 20 goals + 1 assist
02/03 >> 34 matches >> 25 goals + 5 assists
01/02 >> 32 matches >> 23 goals + 1 assist
Last 5 year in PL.. >> 95 goals + 11 assists
Ronaldo:
08/09 >> 33 matches >> 18 goals + 7 assists
07/08 >> 34 matches >> 31 goals + 8 assists
06/07 >> 34 matches >> 17 goals + 17 assists
05/06 >> 33 matches >> 9 goals + 7 assists
04/05 >> 33 matches >> 5 goals + 5 assists
Last 5 year in PL.. >> 80 goals + 44 assists
Berbatov:
12/13 >> 33 matches >> 15 goals + 4 assists (Fulham)
11/12 >> 12 matches >> 7 goals + 0 assists
10/11 >> 32 matches >> 20 goals + 4 assists
09/10 >> 33 matches >> 12 goals + 6 assists
08/09 >> 31 matches >> 9 goals + 11 assists
Last 5 year in PL.. >> 63 goals + 25 assists
van Persie:
13/14 >> 21 matches >> 12 goals + 3 assists
12/13 >> 38 matches >> 26 goals + 15 assists
11/12 >> 38 matches >> 30 goals + 14 assists (Arsenal)
10/11 >> 25 matches >> 18 goals + 7 assists (Arsenal)
09/10 >> 16 matches >> 9 goals + 7 assists (Arsenal)
Last 5 year in PL.. >> 95 goals + 46 assists
Rooney:
13/14 >> 29 matches >> 17 goals + 12 assists
12/13 >> 27 matches >> 12 goals + 10 assists
11/12 >> 34 matches >> 27 goals + 7 assists
10/11 >> 28 matches >> 11 goals + 11 assists
09/10 >> 32 matches >> 26 goals + 5 assists
--------------------------------------------
08/09 >> 30 matches >> 12 goals + 8 assists
07/08 >> 27 matches >> 12 goals + 13 assists
06/07 >> 35 matches >> 14 goals + 12 assists
05/06 >> 36 matches >> 16 goals + 9 assists
04/05 >> 29 matches >> 11 goals + 5 assists
--------------------------------------------
Last 5 year in PL.. >> 93 goals + 45 assists
For Rooney I have put in the last 10 years, just to show on which level he constantly scores / assists. He is the most important and best player for ManU in the last 10 years, imho. A lot of people hate him ,but I like him and his way of playing football.