Alright, am 20 games in so feel like I've got a good handle on what the experience is. Am playing in Career mode, in the prem, as United. Overall this is an excellent game, significantly better than 12. But, a few things feel wrong, I'm hoping people might have ideas for how sliders could help. It's frustrating, cause it's soooo close to being awesome, but not quite:
1. Tackling is just too easy. If any player (even strikers!) get close enough to any other player the ball comes loose. Maybe we could do some kind of editing to take down an ability? There's no slider I can think of that would help.
2. I've yet to score from a cross. In 20+ matches (full manual). I can barely even remember a time one of my strikers (Roon and RVP - hardly crap) even got a head to a cross. The defending on crosses is AMAZING compared to defending in other situations (balls to feet in the box, through balls, high offside line)
Other than those 2 fairly major things (particularly 1) I think the game is brilliant. There's not a HUGE difference in playing different teams, but it's noticeable. Just played Stoke away and it was the most miserable football video game experience ever. I couldn't hold the ball for more than 2 seconds before one of their louts jostled/fouled me. Then played Wigan and waltzed through their midfield with glee.