Bad news for italy

well mate, that's the problem. what's the point in stopping football in italy? This has nothing to do with football. The guys who did this are 80 idiots (80 people who managed to ruin the image of a league followed by 240 millions people!) who weren't even catania supporters!
Those guys were outside the stadium. they didnt' want to see the match. they didn't want to support their team. they went there (i repeat, outside the stadium), with no tickets, with the only purpose of doing this mess. If u stop football, they will find another chance to do this...
the real victims (apart the family of that guy, of course) are us: italian football supporters. we are paying for those few idiots criminals.
:roll: of course its to do with football. and suspending the league is a just way to deal with this, given the severity of the outcome. its the same way people are dealt with as children. you might have a favoured possession confiscated or be excluded from watching tv. hopefully this will make the idiots involved in this behaviour realize what they're doing for the image of their country and its football.

i'd personally hope to see the suspension upheld through to the end of the season.
 
Last edited:
The autopsy revealed the policeman was killed by the stone the murder threw to him a couple of minutes before the explosion of the bomb. The lethal liver haemorrhage was not caused by the bomb that just intoxicated him. No one knows if the person who threw the stone was the same that launched the bomb.
 
Last edited:
Ok mate let me make myself more clear.

i'm 15 years old, i live in a hovel in the poorest district of catania, my mother is unemployed, my father spend 3 months per year in prison, i left school when i was 14, and a'm on my way to become a thief, a drug addicted (or even both). I dont' even know which players actually play for catania (neither palermo), but my friends (maybe 2 or 3 years older than me)know that a stadium is kind of a "no man's land" (as Kleimann correctly said) where i can do EVERYTHING without paying consequences coz the "mass" (the fact of being part of a mass) guarantees me anonymity. Fryday Palermo comes here to play a footbal match....... palermitani and policemans; the perfect situation to unleash my anger without being noticed (coz of the mass).

do u think this has anything to do with football? I don't care about football. i've never been inside a stadium. i just wanna have some "fun" with my "friends". U stop football in italy? who cares! I'll do the same things in other circumstances, maybe a politic manifestation (ever heard about black block?).

a couple of years ago in genova a guy was killed by the police during the manifestation against the G8 meeting. this guy was shot while he was trying to assault a police car with a fire extinguisher! Do u think that guy reallly did really care about politic? he was just unleashing his anger. he could have done this during the g8 or during a football match. he was just looking for a chance to do this.

So what a civil society should do? shall we stop every activity that could represent a chance for disorders? that's not a way to solve the problem.... that's a way to avoid it. that's not mature, not wise.

i love football i've always supported my team, since they played in serie c. I love to go to the stadium and enjoy a footbal match. and i don't wanna pay the consequence of the actions of a bunch of 16 years old morons.

what england did to solve their problem? did they banned football? What germany did? their situation were even tougher than ours, but thay managed to solve it.

stopping football in italy is just a way to say: "ok, we give up, u won! our society just can afford to face this 4 stupid little gangsters.
 
Last edited:
Thatlast post of lo zio is great...completely agree.
The pro-english league people are extremely biased and feel strong because they sense they are on their home turf...virtual world does acknowledge nationalities let alone chauvinists....

Once again this has nothing to do with football...it is "merely" a coïncidence that this happened in the margin of a football match.

Football however has to be cleaned up (and not alone in Italy, as a matter of fact things happening in England at clubs like Chelsea, Man Utd, Aston Villa, West Ham United and soon Liverpool are far more worrying).
 
Just to complete my previous consideration.


i'd personally hope to see the suspension upheld through to the end of the season.

ok, let's suppose that this suspension last till the end of the season. then what? what shall we do next season? just start the whole thing like nothing happened? Do u think those thugs will learn something? Just cause we stopped the whole thing for 1, 2, 3 years? do u think those guys will magically become polite, law respectful? can one year without football supply an entire life without education?
sure it would be nice.... but it isn't so simple.

let's suppose your city is full of criminals. what's the solution? just closing each bank?
a civil counrty got to face his problems, not hide them.
 
The pro-english league people are extremely biased

i'm starting to think that that's the problem when u live in an island...... no matter how big it is :lol:

btw i got a brand new anti-bias signature :D


things happening in England at clubs like Chelsea, Man Utd, Aston Villa, West Ham United and soon Liverpool are far more worrying

i still remember the hell that west ham supporters brought here in palermo, when they came last year fo a uefa cup match....

3 cars burned.....

2 pubs destroyed.....

......a couple of them being jailed by police.....
things like theese never happened in palermo before

.... and i prefere not to express myself about their disgusting shirt
my.php
[/URL][/IMG]
 
Last edited:
I am unsure about how this should be dealt with. I love watching Italian football and still believe its one of the best leagues in the world. I would like to see the shoe on the other foot though if this were an English problem. I remember many calls for England to be kicked out of International football a few years ago when we had a few dodgy moments and felt it would be a shame if we suffered because of some idiots. I really don't know what s best for Italian football and football in general. One thing for sure fans rioting with other fans and the police is not the way forward. Closed door games seems the obvious action IMO, look what happened to Inter in Europe after the flare incident against Milan a few years back. Roma also had the coin incident and if my memory is correct the either got a points deduction or a ban for the fans. Something along these lines are a minimum for this weekends problem. If another team within Italy does something similar then give them that ban also. I think a total ban would be OTT and counter productive but something has to be done.

If this problem continues then I am sorry to say some sort of more sever ban would have to come into effect. Its not lazy its containing potential problems in the future. What would be lazy, nothing being done about it. Letting it go on and another death but it shouldn't take a death to look more serious at such problems. I am to young too remember what happened through the 80's though I am aware. English clubs were taken out of European competition due to idiots. So since its not a European problem (though in reality it does effect the rest of Europe) its an Italian problem so the equivalent punishment is not that far fetched IMO.

I don't think all that bad of Italians its something that does get on my nerve when they are all perceived as Nazi's, animals and such like. I am aware that such people may exist in the population of the country the same way that they exist in England. I do think the minority are becoming less, hopefully this continues.
 
Closed door games seems the obvious action IMO,

i see your point mate. but if u consider that theese thugs weren't footbal fans, the whole things will appear too u quite different.

those guys were outside the stadium. what kind of fan wouldn't buy a ticket for the most important match of the year? (as i wrote before there's a big rivalry between palermo and catania).

hear what u can do if u got a bunch of 16 years old morons that follow your orders like u were god. i can have a talk to palermo's chairman and say to him..
"give me 5000 euros or next week i'll make so big disorders outside the stadium that your team will play for a couple of closed doors matches.
that's the choice for palermo's chairman: paying theese criminals, or loose the incomes of a couple of matches.

as u can see close door matches may appear the most fast ans obvious solution..... but maybe it isn't a solution.
if theese guys are not supporters they won't pay for their action as they don't care about football. the only one who will pay are palermo supporters (like me)
......... and palermo's chairman, of course.


look what happened to Inter in Europe after the flare incident against Milan a few years back. Roma also had the coin incident and if my memory is correct the either got a points deduction or a ban for the fans

are u sure they solved their problem? i'm not :(
 
Last edited:
Once again this has nothing to do with football...it is "merely" a coïncidence that this happened in the margin of a football match.

exact! :applause:
and that's the real problem. if it were just a football fans problem the solution would be much more easier (Cloud's solution would be perfect).

sorry for double posting :)
 
yes its bad news for all ppl not only italy
i think the sud of italy is so different than the north
but its realy bad that happens in the best league
 
i think the sud of italy is so different than the north

:?:

here in Palermo we never had any problem.

sure we're not all gentlemen. we got criminals, like everywhere in the world..... but we never had any disorder..... inside or ouside the stadium :)
 
I love watching Italian football and still believe its one of the best leagues in the world.

I would have agreed with this statement in between the years 1990-2000 but it has since become ugly, boring & cheating football. There is way too much scandal now and all of the good players have left for other European leagues. The crowd attendances are appalling and the quality of football is in rapid decline. The Old Lady was a disgrace to football worldwide last season and I wish they would rot in Serie B with their overrated, ageing old men of players. A lot of members in this thread are on about "Pro-English" comments. Wrong. When ANYONE says anything against Italian football you prove to be the most biased members on a forum I have ever seen. Who is the exciting talent in Serie A at the moment? When are the Italian football clubs going to stop racist nazi supporters carrying knives into their poor-attended matches? Why wasn't AC Milan & Juventus made BIGGER EXAMPLES of with the match fixing & scandal? The latest murder just adds to the problems that Italian football faces.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
ok mate your statements are really intersting and original, but u repeated the same things in 3 posts. i'm sure everybody understood your point of view, dont' u think?

Moreover u're quite off topic. We're not talking about Serie a's quality here. Maybe u can open a new thread: "serie a. how much it sucks?" :)

but please, stop posting here, coz each time u post, i read, thinking u're up to say something smart........ and i always get disappointed :(


otherwise i'll hit u with my "knife" :lol:
 
:?:

here in Palermo we never had any problem.

sure we're not all gentlemen. we got criminals, like everywhere in the world..... but we never had any disorder..... inside or ouside the stadium :)
dnt miss understand me i mean they are hard fans and little
Fanatics just like the fans in my original country libia
I remember once I was there in the stadium i Applauded for opponent team chance then i didnt remember anything except that
i had a black eye and the who was sitting near me who did hit me
:D
 
El Diego
u don't like watching Italian football its ur problem but there are millions like it
scandals every where ...but i love italian footbal for one reason
u cant know who is the champion until the last mins except this
crazy season ..
 
dnt miss understand me i mean they are hard fans and little
Fanatics just like the fans in my original country libia
I remember once I was there in the stadium i Applauded for opponent team chance then i didnt remember anything except that
i had a black eye and the who was sitting near me who did hit me
:D

well mate, i don't know about Libia, but i know about Palermo.
Last year di michele used to play for udinese. udinese came came here and smashed us 0 - 5. di michele scored 3 goals. when he went out of the field the crowd was applauding for him (still remember his astonished face :lol: )



i Applauded for opponent team
anyway if i may suggest , i wouldn't do it again, but not only in Libia..... everywhere. Applauding for opponent team near to a football fan is not so..... wise :mrgreen:



let's stay on topic, btw
 
hear what u can do if u got a bunch of 16 years old morons that follow your orders like u were god. i can have a talk to palermo's chairman and say to him..
"give me 5000 euros or next week i'll make so big disorders outside the stadium that your team will play for a couple of closed doors matches.
that's the choice for palermo's chairman: paying theese criminals, or loose the incomes of a couple of matches.
(

:shock: :shock: Catania's chairman is on tv right now. he said that it happened exactly what i described before! :shock:
he's saying that in the last few years some criminals blackmailed him.

i say have closed door matches its better than nothing

so, as u can see, this isn't a solution, mate. btw the choice is not "closed doors or nothing" we got a few possibilities.

1 - dismantle ultras clubs

2 - stadia owned by clubs

3 - APPLYING THE PISANO ACT! (that's the better solution imo). last year we approved a good law..... BUT WE NEVER APPLIED IT (and i can see it every week). this sure would be more useful than closed door matches (if u close tha stadia, they will just find another place to go...... and let me repeat it one more time: the whole thing happened outside the stadium)
 
@ lo Zio: I get what you are saying about morons that are not true football fans, but my point is more about the general state in Italy. This situation mearley tipped the iceberg. Some of those people rioting were fans, what you would call true fans and I bet the majority were not this. Maybe the person who killed this policeman was a stupid 16 year old boy maybe he was a 30 year old lover of the club but this to me is irrelevant of the outcome. A man died in the name of football. If this game of football never went on this situation wouldn't not have happened. This is not about football fans this is about thugs, but the thugs use football to do their bidding. Therefore football is going to be the loser, they use the sport as their tool so the only way to fight them is to control or stop their tool. Please tell me a method that would fight these idiots? The only way is the harshest option, the problems in England were bad and we never shut down our leagues, I don't know if we played matches behind closed doors. But the real damage was done writhing European competition and through this English clubs were kicked out. This was they way to stop that problem and it may be the way to stop it in Italy. Again I want to stress this it not how I think it should be handled the now, the matches should be played in empty grounds. This is not for the whole Italy just the parties concerned. If any trouble happens in the future the club who's fans cause it should have this as a minimal instance punishment.

About Inter well maybe it hasn't stopped it so far but do you suggest the authorities should do, nothing? Just hope that it will go away without effecting the games.

PS About the argumtnt about this happening outside the stadium again this for me does not make much difference. There were problems inside the stadium during this match and during many matches in Italy.
 
Last edited:
@ lo Zio: they use the sport as their tool so the only way to fight them is to control or stop their tool.

perfect mate. your image (the tool) fits perfectly. they used a football match as a tool. but in an opened society there are a lot of "tools" so if u operate on that "tool" they will just find another one.


I get what you are saying about morons that are not true football fans

that's the point. i never talked about "true football fans" or "not true football fans". According to what i'm listening right now on the tv, these aren't football fans at all. let take the example i did before (wich is not anymore an example, as catania's chairman said that this is what really happened in the last years in catania)..

i can have a talk to palermo's chairman and say to him..
"give me 5000 euros or next week i'll make so big disorders outside the stadium that your team will play for a couple of closed doors matches.
that's the choice for palermo's chairman: paying theese criminals, or loose the incomes of a couple of matches.

now let's imagine we're talking about rugby. i'm not a palermo's rugby team fan. i don't know anything about rugby, i just don't care about it. i never saw a rugby match and i won't ever do as i don't like it, u follow me?
now, i have a talk with palermo's rugby team and i blackmail him the way i wrote before. what if, after the disorders i caused (me and my "gang"), palermo's rugby team plays a couple of closed doors matches? Will this be a punishment for me? No, coz i just don't care about rugby. this will be a punishment for rugby supporters and for palermo's rugby team's chairman. i'm not a "true rugby fan".... i'm not even a "bad rugby fan".... i'm just a criminal, and i found a chance to make easy money. here it is.




Please tell me a method that would fight these idiots?

here's my reply: :)

1 - dismantle ultras clubs

2 - stadia owned by clubs

3 - APPLYING THE PISANO ACT!




but do you suggest the authorities should do, nothing? Just hope that it will go away without effecting the games.


here it is again

1 - dismantle ultras clubs

2 - stadia owned by clubs

3 - APPLYING THE PISANO ACT!

sorry for all this "self-quoting" :lol:

i'm not saying we don't have to do annything. i'm just saying that we have to find a better solution, as closed doors match won't solve anything.
12 years ago a genoa supporter died in a match against milan. u know what we did. league stopped for a week and a couple of closed doors matches........ and now, after 12 years, we're at the same point.
we already did a mistake 12 years ago, now we have another chance to really change something. i hope this time we'll be wiser
 
Last edited:
so do I but all the pro-english league people dont
What is pro English in this thread, I don't get it? I completely agree with what lo zio said then as well. But examples of this happen all over Europe. The difference is how each country deals with the same problem. The Italian authorities are not doing anywhere near enough to combat radical groups of hooligans. It is understandable if they wish to shut the leagues down in the short term. They need to set in place clear initiatives or this sort of thing could happen in a months time or even next week.

The pro-english league people are extremely biased and feel strong because they sense they are on their home turf...virtual world does acknowledge nationalities let alone chauvinists....
Who are you referring to here? This comment could be seen as quite offensive. Making a statement about disregarding facts based on nationality. Base statements that users have posted on them, and not the country they are from. What on earth does "home turf" have to do with anything? I know some comments have been clearly chauvinistic, but pinpoint those comments or clearly label individuals.
Once again this has nothing to do with football...it is "merely" a coïncidence that this happened in the margin of a football match.

Football however has to be cleaned up (and not alone in Italy, as a matter of fact things happening in England at clubs like Chelsea, Man Utd, Aston Villa, West Ham United and soon Liverpool are far more worrying).
Well it does have something to do with football actually. How can the link be disregarded. Sure violence exists outside of the game, we obviously know that. But football becomes a breeding ground and focal point to direct the animosity of those taking part. This is not an isolated incident. If the Italian powers are issuing a full scale threat to their national game, it must be a large scale problem. These things aren't done on a whim surely.

I also find it hard to take you reference to the high profile takeovers of English clubs in recent times. Although it is somewhat worrying that some clubs are under the control of outside investment, as long as it is above board and beneficial to the club I don't see a problem. If you invest in a football club you will lose a lot of money, fact. The overseas investors are the only businessmen willing to do this it seems. How is this more worrying than the problems a country like Italy has with corruption and violence? The two are incomparable. It is well known that Italy needs to address these areas. It's time they cleaned up the game. We should all want that. If it takes canceling football for a period to do that then so be it.

This is nothing to do with me being pro English at all, I have nothing against Italian football whatsoever. But lets put this serious situation in context a bit. Football is nothing in importance compared to the underlying issues there are.
 
Last edited:
@ ad16:
mate, i'm sure Stan wasn't referring to anyone in particular (sorry stan, for replying at your place, but it looks like i've got nothing to do this sunday :lol: ). Probably he was talking about the whole english community in this forum.
actually i got to say i noticed it too. obviously isn't just an englishmen problem. there are a lot of italian and french chauvinist too (even in this forum :roll: ), but the english community is the biggest in this forum, so it is more evident :)

The difference is how each country deals with the same problem. The Italian authorities are not doing anywhere near enough to combat radical groups of hooligans.

:applause: :applause: :applause:
exactly


If the Italian powers are issuing a full scale threat to their national game, it must be a large scale problem. These things aren't done on a whim surely.

true. that's the point of this thread :)


If you invest in a football club you will lose a lot of money

believe me mate, this is far from being true. Do u think abramovich, or arabians, or glazer did the whole thing just for popularity? football is an asset very profitable.I know it may sounds weird, according to the amount of money spent by football clubs owners, but marketing and advertising rules are weird actually)
Palermo's chairman owns almost 100 supermarket in italy. Last year he said that his profits increased a lot since he bought palermo (and he said it was cause he bought palermo).
otherwise he wouldn't have any interest in buying palermo footbal club...... is not even born in palermo.
btw let's get back to the topic.


How is this more worrying than the problems a country like Italy has with corruption and violence?
it isn't :)

But lets put this serious situation in context a bit. Football is nothing in importance compared to the underlying issues there are.
of course :)
 
Last edited:
lo zio
totally agree with you
i dont know why u guys make it coz of italian football its so bad
and it happens everywhere its mistake they need to solve it correctly
not by another mistake like closed doors matches
 
@ ad16:
mate, i'm sure Stan wasn't referring to anyone in particular (sorry stan, for replying at your place, but it looks like i've got nothing to do this sunday :lol: ). Probably he was talking about the whole english community in this forum.
actually i got to say i noticed it too. obviously isn't just an englishmen problem. there are a lot of italian and french chauvinist too (even in this forum :roll: ), but the english community is the biggest in this forum, so it is more evident :)

I just looked at what Stan was on about and I cant actually see what he starting a problem about in the first place.

The English superiority complex is visible in this thread...i would think that football fans from the nation that "invented" hooliganism should express themselves a litle bit more carefull.

To me that is a dig, a bit of a well you did it so you have no right to make comment, which to me is an insult.

I dont think its all pro-English either apart from the usual suspect/s. :p

I think the comment is actually anti-English, I guess thats just my opinion though.
 
To me that is a dig, a bit of a well you did it so you have no right to make comment, which to me is an insult.

I dont think its all pro-English either apart from the usual suspect/s. :p

I think the comment is actually anti-English, I guess thats just my opinion though.

if u read carefully all the posts in that page (the first) u'll understand why he talked like this ;)

it's not about "anti-English feelings" ;)


gettin' back on topic: the numbers of jailed people is 27 now (10 of them under 18 years old)
 
Stan posting as Gerd (sorry i have two nicks).
My comment was never intended as anti-English. If people perceive it that way: i'm deeply sorry. I never wanted to hurt people's feelings. I love English football, that's why i keep coming at this forum.

BUT...

Just like lo zio and other foreign people (i'm Belgian), i do sense some sort of superiority feeling with quite a few of the English people on this forum.
Some examples:
"There is no doubt, the Premiership is by far the strongest league". Well, as much as i like it, i'm not quite sure it is...but that does not matter in this thread...it's the fact that people who doubt this perception are seen as anti-English...we are not anti-English. The fact that i'm a member for more than 5 years and haven't got a single "yellow card" proves that.

Second example:

Every time before a major tournament like WC or EC there is the massive gulf of expectation that the English national team will win it this time...when foreign people doubt the favourite role people react bad...yet every time in the end they are proven right...i make it a rule of thumb never to visit this forum on a night when the English national team has been eliminated in a major tournament...but the fact that you have to do that proves enough...

Third example:
The wrong perception of the achoievements of English club teams in the CL...to me and to most non-English people on this forum they are underachieving. Since the CL exists, merely two English teams have won it...Man Utd in 1999 and Liverpool in 2005. Yet among the twenty richest sports teams in the world are 4 English football teams...given the importance of money in sports, i call that underachiving. Each time i point this out there is aggro (reactions among the line of: you have no right to say that until Belgian teams are getting better results than English, which is highly irrelevant).

In this thread (at the beginning) a few English people had very degrading comments about one of the the biggest football nations in the world, if you don't see that...you are seriously biased.

About the take-overs of big clubs: read about the way Abromovich took over Chelsea (and how he earned that money) or how Glazier put himself in debt and transferred those debts to Man Utd...not good for both clubs and certainly not for football. The English Premiership is not a fair competition...there is a huge gap between the top 4 and the rest...English (and European) football needs rules like NBA (i've said that countless times on this forum). In the long term this more worrying than the death of a single police men (how much this may be a tragedy for the man and his family and for Italian society).

To end: once again i don't want to hurt anyone's feelings, if i did: once again i'm very sorry...the two people who reacted are sensible people, my comment about English superiority certainly was not about them and i can understand that they feel offended.
 
I think some of that superiority is actually English people feeling a little hard done to. We were banned from Europe for 5 years whereas other nations seemed to get away with a lot. Every week we saw footage of violence from Turkey, Greece, Germany and Holland but nothing was ever done about it. Admittedly we were probably the worst offenders but we were the only ones that were punished.
When we see it happening in other countries we sometimes over react a little and demand something is done.

Before that ban, we were arguably the strongest nation in european competitions, and we're only really getting near that again now.
 
Last edited:
Every week we saw footage of violence from Turkey, Greece, Germany and Holland but nothing was ever done about it. Admittedly we were probably the worst offenders but we were the only ones that were punished.

mate, that's not true. each year some teams get punished for their violent attitude. but the organization has to punish the results of violence and they can be really different.

feyenoor got a punishment balanced with their actions. in the past few years inter, Roma, an galatasaray got a punishment balanced to their actions.

friday catanesi had a violent attitude, and they will get a punishment balanced to the results of their attitude (1 man death)...

..but in 1989 96 people died. i'd say there's a difference. Yesterday i saw on the tv a reportage on english hooligans and i saw something really scaring, mate.... there's a difference. and there must be a difference in the punishment too. it is quite obvious, don't u think? :)



When we see it happening in other countries we sometimes over react a little and demand something is done.

i can understand this kind of reaction. And i don't think is a "over" reaction. 1 man died friday. and something HAS to be done.






Before that ban, we were arguably the strongest nation in european competitions, and we're only really getting near that again now.


Perfect mate, what i'm going to write is HIGHLY off topic, but if this can be the chance to write something important, let it be.

u say "we were arguably the strongest". Well i think this is the wrongest thing u can say when u talk about sport. and this because sport is not about arguing. sport is about fact! FACT.

the most beautiful thing in sport is that it is simple. a football match will always get a result (in real life this happens rarely). Now u can face this result or not; it's up to u. But the results ALWAYS HAS TO TELL WHO WAS THE BEST IN THAT COMPETITION. Because if u don't accept the result, if u say "yes they won, but we were better! they didn't really deserve it", well when u talk like this the COMPETITION HAS NO MEANING. Sport has no meaning.

u're saying that before '89 england was the best. But do u remember which players argentina had between '80 and '90? well, i remember them. I remember burruchaga, caniggia, kempes, maradona, passerella ruggeri, valdano....
i remember germany, i remember matthaus, klinsmann, kholer, rummenigge, voeller.

mate those were the strongest teams those days. and it is not arguably, coz the results says it. they played the final of mexico '86. and if u are a sportman, u have to accept the result and honor the winner. by saying the england was "arguably" the best, u humiliate those who really won something those years. and u humiliate yourself (coz u admit that u can't face a result).
those years england wasnt' even right behind argentina and germany. behind them there was France and an impressive belgium. that's what the result says. we play in a competition to discover who is the best, so what's the point in playing if then u say "we were arguably the best"?

There was a big hype around england football team last summer, but i really didn't understand why. did u really thought england was better than the others. How can u compare 2 different top players?
I mean, u can compare me to Lampard. Lampard is for sure better than me( :roll: ). But how can u compare Lampard to Totti? They're both world class player. it's not possible to "argue" about who is the best.

let's try to "compare" pirlo and gerrard. i'd say now gerrard is playing better than pirlo. but 6 months ago pirlo was playing better (actually he was really on another level).
Then what? do u think pirlo became a worst player, or gerrard improved? It is not about that. We're talking about top players so u can't say who is absolutely the best . but u can see them playing better or worst according to their mood, to their motivations.

u can compare a ferrari to an alfa romeo. "arguably" a ferrari will be faster. But u can't compare a ferrari to a lamborghini. they're both top performances cars, maybe a ferrari is better in a curvish circuit while a lamborghini may be better on a straight circuit.

as u can see in theese cases details, circumstances, may be decisive.

do u wanna know wich national played the best soccer in the last wc? imo it wasn't italy, neither france or england; they were argentina and germany.
but u won't ever hear me say that argentina and germany deserved the title more than us or france. because that would mean denying the result. that would mean humiliating italy achievements and france achievements.

germany and argentina showed the most beautiful football. but footbal is not about playing "joga bonito". football is not about being "arguably" the best. football is about win or loose, and that's all. it's simple (and that's why it is so beautiful).

germany, agentina, france, italy, brazil, holland, portugal..... they're all top teams. u can't compare them. they had a competition, and (as always) details were decisive.
in football details are mood, conditioning, and, most important WILL.

italy won cause our players will was impressive. do u wanna know why cannavaro was better than terry (just to make an example)?
because cannavaro had to show that he still was the best in his role. because he had to show to every club in the world that he still was a "good buy" (real madrid?). terry hadn't this will cause his future was "safer". the same can be said for pirlo, gattuso, zambrotta, oddo, and all the other guys.
if u wanna know my opinion, without Moggi's scandal, we wouldn't have won the wc.
our players where hungry. they were more hungry than the others and that's all.........DETAILS, that's the only difference when u talk about top players.

and that's the reason why brazil won more wc than everybody else. not because the always had the strongest team, but because they're always hungry.

the difference between a winner and a loser most of the times is not quality........ is WILL, is BEING HUNGRY
 
Last edited:
Lo zio while i agree with your reaction, i think you misunderstood marukomu's reply.
I think he was talking about the English club teams in European competitions before Heysel...and then one has to be objective: English clubs dominated European club football (Euro Cups for Liverpool, Nottingham Forest, Aston Villa, Everton, Spurs). As a matter of fact there is no arguing, English teams simply were the best in those years.
I don't agree with his "catching up" argument...with the money getting so much more important, the catching up was done in one season right at the start of the Premiership...
 
In this thread (at the beginning) a few English people had very degrading comments about one of the the biggest football nations in the world, if you don't see that...you are seriously biased.
Of course, these degrading comments are there to see.

I understand the examples you have chosen in the rest of this post as well. They tie in with the subject of the English media over in PLF's thread, In which I have criticized my countries press on many occasions. It's obvious that the some of themselves and the majority of English fans don't see past the premiership, but you can't say this concludes a superiority complex, more, naivety and lack of knowledge in my opinion. Just like foreign individuals who state that English food is rubbish, without basis whatsoever. This is a stereotype that still sticks to the present day.

Listen, we all know that each of our countries have superiority issues, that's a fact. There's just no need to bring up a perceived English one in relation to a couple of idiotic posts. Those comments were stupid, quite stupid indeed. But when you mention things like English superiority to describe these people, it groups them with individuals like myself, which gives me a label I am not comfortable with. That's the reason I took exception to some of your previous comments. I know you probably didn't mean harm, but you understand I needed to question it.


As for what marukomu said, it's not a view I chose to believe. I don't feel hard done by at all when it comes to past events. I try to stick impartial when it comes to football so that's to be expected. I do feel hard done by in situations like this however, where past events are used almost like a comeback.
"i would think that football fans from the nation that "invented" hooliganism should express themselves a litle bit more carefull".
Like Cloud1863 was getting at, this is the wrong attitude and sounded a bit cheap in my opinion. There was provocation from those chauvinistic comments, but this wasn't needed, especially when it referred to a part of the post that technically stated the truth. Italy does have a problem with hooliganism.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom