Regarding the discussion about 360 movement, I remember back in 2010 how important and how groundbreaking it would be, How over due it was and that it was the missing piece in football gaming immersion and realism.
It's a funny thing how as we age we simply understand things to be less important than we blew them up to be when we was younger. That when FIFA introduced 360 dribbling before PES, The latter was somehow inferior. Here we are in this Retro Corner acknowledging how insignificant the 360 dribbling can be to an experience, That 8 directions is fine enough for these vintage games and even the 16 directions of PES 2010 adds enough fluidity in movement without it becoming a icy prototype that PES 2011 was (Despite being a really good game still).
I could show a friend who's only reference is modern gaming; Retro PES and he would laugh at the "Limited" nature of the games & it's 8 directions but i guarantee after a couple of games of PS2 PES, You'll be having too much fun to notice.
Hit the nail in the head. All these years I've been wanting football games to become hyper-realistic, a photocopy of the real deal on all aspects; and now here I am, playing 15/20-ish year old games on a regular basis, completely ignoring modern games. Ten, fifteen years ago I was dreaming of bringing real football onto a virtual platform; now, in a bit I'll be starting up a 13-year-old football game and edit the kits of the Antarctica football league there. I did not foresee this at all...
On one hand, these games are undeniably challenging, entertaining and realistic enough to feel like football, regardless of the technology that was used to build it. That's the mark of a real classic. I mean, no, I can't start a Pokemon Blue save and expect it to have 2019 graphics; but if one accepts that platform and plays the game as it is, it'll be impossible for him not to enjoy himself as he did in the late 90s when it was released. He'll live to see the day when his grandson calls him to say: "you know granpa, I wasn't expecting to say this but that Pokemon Blue game you told me about...it's goddamn amazing!".
Yet, despite the actual undeniable value of some of these games, there's also the subjective aspect of the experience. I for example am completely biased when it comes to ISS Pro Evo because it was my first ISS/PES on the PS1. People will say I'm nostalgic; if so...who cares? The thing is, while they are playing the game of PES20, I'm not actually playing a game of ISS Pro Evo. That is not a game anymore: it's a time machine that not only allows me to travel back in time but also gives me the opportunity of playing a fantastic game of football while I do it. (Yes, my time machine has ISS Pro Evo installed on it, why do you ask?) We're talking about playable memories here, and no modern game can even begin to compete with such a potent idea like that.
Which brings me to the point about this also being a subjective experience: it's not about playing the most modern of games just because they're modern; it's not about playing what game reviewers recommend; it's about you playing what you want and like to play. Maybe you're biased, maybe you don't know any better, but...who cares? It's your call and yours alone.
----
About your PES2010 adventure, man your commentary was already fantastic but you're clearly stepping up your game judging by that video. Bravo!
I have mixed feelings about PES10. The soundtrack is definitely amazing, probably my favourite among all PES games; the ML was an instant classic indeed. I replayed the game a while ago and found that it plays a very PES-5-like, patient, scrappy game when you're using really weak teams, and turns into a galloping fest most of the time when using great sides. I wouldn't say this is a vapid ex-girlfriend of yours, she's got a great ass and a beautiful singing voice but she's no Ana de Armas, vis-a-vis, ISS Pro Evolution...

Oh and the lighting. It doesn't quite show on the stadiums you use there, but here you get to see it:
so strange, it's like a footballing version of David Lynch's Mulholland Drive. Even stranger, considering the lighting was really good in PES09.