I spent an hour looking for the evidence of Asim straight up lying yesterday. Came here, posted it, and nobody seemed to care.
The problem is, as someone pointed out, saying "the shadows move across the pitch" isn't a lie. At half time, shadows that were in one position, switch to a different position. It's not a lie - it's just horribly worded.
Deceitfully so? Why? Who's going to buy the game because shadows move? What would they get out of lying other than angry nerds? Who would be so stupid to think we wouldn't find out the lie (by playing the game for about five minutes)?
PLEASE don't get me wrong here - I don't think anyone would have read his statement and NOT assumed he meant real-time shadow movement of some sort. But poorly worded doesn't mean "lie". Our emotional response to stuff like this is off-the-scale - I saw your tweets at Asim where you were screaming "CANCELLING PRE-ORDER"... It just doesn't help.
(Nothing does - I'm all out of hope, to be honest. But that's not Asim's fault, or Adam's fault. We seem to need a scapegoat - and it's never a producer, or a developer. How crazy is that?)
It's like the code changes. There are people who've played the initial preview code and said "this is amazing", then played the latest code and said "this is faster, more assisted, what happened". There is a 0% chance that the reason behind that is to fool people - how much difference are 10 people at a preview event going to make to sales?
Especially when they follow it up with "the new code is worse"?!
But every year (because, yes, this sequence of events does seem to happen every year), a few people will say "they're trying to fool us all". Without ever thinking "what difference would it actually make?"
If they'd promised all-new gameplay and a new super-sim approach, I'd be angry. But they said "shadows move". Honestly, I can't make myself care about that.
I may be wrong, but I think that's why, when you pointed it out - as you said...
...nobody seemed to care.
(See, this essay DID have a point, it wasn't just the ramblings of a madman...)