i respect your opinion but how on earth do you think konami are in the driving seat? in my opinion it certainly isn't gameplay - fifa's has its faults yes but the ball physics and collision detection are light years ahead
Thing is what does Ball physics and collision detection add to your thought process within the gameplay. Like i was explaining regarding movement in PES 2011-13, if i know like in every fifa, every single player will handle the same way, some faster, some slower, tactics wont affect the game much so you know in certain positions you will be favored to score more than others, what does slightly better ball physics, deflections along with nice jostling physics force me to change my mind in how I play if i know each player moves and turns in the same way?
If I'm playing FIFA, I have a very fast winger not matter his ball control i know i can thread balls into him and he will reach into positions where i know he's going to score, I really don't see how nice ball physics and collision detentions really going to change much. There maybe a nice example of some ball physics but that will not change the predictability since every player will have the same linear ball control style, so i know if i keep possession and thread the ball into certain positions i'm going to score regardless of the AI or human.
I think it's far more important for the most basic things such as stats preventing and enabling certain play-styles, creating variables which make me change my thought process. If i have Theo Walcott or Gabriel Agbonglahor, i don't want to like in FIFA be able to dribble past 4-5 players which i can do because he's fast, they beat players with pace not their dropping of the shoulder and quick change of direction! I want to use his pace by just sprinting full pelt with him into space, off the shoulder of the last defender or on the break! This is where PES are miles ahead, the basic things which make you think and have to change and adapt your style.
FIFA is still stuck in the imagination mode where you play at 60% and play in a certain style you feel is realistic but if you go full pelt your win easily. Like i said with the technology, Konami are still in PS3 level mode with PES 2015 whereas EA have moved to the PS4 level, EA's philosophy is still like in the PS1/PS2 days just with far better physics and quality animations (well up until about FIFA 14, the animations don't seem very good in 15) but the thought process isn't much different at all, such an easy game to play.
PES 2014 had great jostling physics and very good ball physics, best in any football game but was a horrible game to play, horrible and broken.
Please don't talk about manual, I was and always have played manual in FIFA and PES, i was very good at manual back in FIFA 09, apart from getting mashed by this Finnish dude Puzulu i did well in my manual league, manual shouldn't be hard either if EA could program the thing properly so you didn't have to use through ball for short passes because of sensitivity problems.
-konami are still using the stumble animation from years ago and fouls are virtually none existent and the passing scripted.
Valid points, i don't know about the fouls, this should be dependent on how well you dribble and how good the CPU dribblers are, it should also depend on tactics, some games have very few fouls are are open or just full of incompetent play, some games are full of aggressive tackles, it varies depending on players and tactics! You must also factor in some fouls given in real life cant be shown ingame because they are unfair such as pulling shirts on free kicks and corners, climbing etc...
Also the demo is played with short time limits so we must wait and see if like in 2011-13 the gameplay gets more simulation the longer you set it on.
Then there is the whole package, the sound, the atmosphere, the presentation, the game modes that immerse you - again FIFA in the driving seat. This all leads to the most important factor for development and investment, the sales. And i'd bet my house FIFA will be streets ahead on that too
What immerses me is the mental challenge, not the aesthetic one, it's like you can be rich and get a narcissistic, psychopathic pretty girlfriend, she will get draw in by your aesthetics, things is after 2-3 months she gets used to the diamonds and if the love isn't present which it wasn't at the beginning it all comes crashing down like a car crash in slow motion.