I agree and disagree, it is the most realistic representation of the sport but it hardly has much competition. That said, I do still love the series and despite it nearly causing me to throw my TV out of the window it still has that 'one more go' factor that, for me, the competition simply doesn't have. However, it still is a bug ridden mess. As fun as the game can be, there are more issues with the game than any other I've ever played.
I mean I've come across these issues:
- Bizarre collision detection where I can be running in full control of the ball, someone bumps into the side of me and the ref calls for a foul against me.
- Player switching issues totally removing control from my players with the worst possible timing.
- Occasional bizarre GK moments, where they come miles out of their area.
- Very rare occurences where the keeper just doesn't react at all, instead he runs towards the ball at someone's feet like he's going to pick it up, and the ball is kicked into an unguarded net
- Bizarre shooting issues where shots go in the completely opposite direction to where your direction stick and even player body position dictate.
- AI issues where your defenders 'pause' their run off the ball, allowing the CPU to run in on goal or leaves them with an easy chance on goal, mainly with through-balls.
- Dodgy AI marking where defenders just run away from their marker and off in a bizarre direction in their own six-yard-box moments before a cross comes in.
- I scored a goal recently that hit the underside of the bar and was clearly visible as being over the line, but again, I presume some kind of collision detection issues meant it didn't register as a goal.
Oh, and the bug that occurred the other night where the ball went off for a goal kick, I paused the game and pressed replay, then saw there were no players on the pitch during that replay. I came out of that, un-paused the game, and the CPU keeper refused to take his goal kick. I then realised I had control of my player, and to my amusement was able to run him into the penalty area, and could acutally take the ball from where the CPU was going to take its goal kick, and scored a goal that was allowed to stand
I do see what you say, there are plenty of amazing positives about the game, but the number of issues and bugs does still really need sorting.