The only review I've seen so far that mentions any negatives.
He ends by saying it feels like a big step back in depth and immersion. Ouch.
That feels a little harsh, but then it feels like every other reviewer is keeping things positive because SI have said "it's alpha right now"...
...but how is it an alpha with a month until release?
The downsides he covers in short:
- Pass maps and heat maps have gone (WHAT?!)
- Transfer deadline day has gone (which I loved)
- Live cup draws have gone
- No more multi-friendly options, e.g. leagues, cups or tours
- Friendlies are arranged magically and you can't stop that from happening
- You can't click on a training day and easily change the week's training now
- A lot of the game is uncustomisable (which was the whole point of the tile system) e.g. player profiles can't be changed to have pros/cons on the first tab
- FPS issues even on hardware far above the minimum requirements
- Randomly disappearing UI elements
- Appalling regen faces