So, about my recent adventure on 19.
It started when I stumbled in an old career of a youtuber I follow. My biggest turn off playing this particular edition always has been that it felt too easy, at any kind of difficulty level. Yet this guy was having his butt kicked hard, here and there.
Then, in search for some novelty, I decided to install it once again. Can't remember which sliders I had on, but it didn't took too long to identify that they clearly were the problem: whatever better rythm they gave me, they destroyed any CPU competitivity. And the guy above played it all on default.
Given this, I started a career with Parma at Legendary with more or less all on default as well, aside from injuries and some other few things and well.. was hooked from the get go.
Results wise, the first few seasons were straight up miserable. My team being piss poor, CPU being ruthless with normal teams and almost impossible to play with top ones, the grind for points was quite hard, but very enjoyable all the same (will expand on the gameplay later). Playing a 3-4-1-2, I remember avoiding relegation only in the last few matches in my first season, and then ending up middle of the table or slightly lower in the subsequent 2-3 ones- only really appreciable transfer being Tonali (who's the only guy, togheter with Cardoso, a brazilian cb from the youths, I brought up to the lowest from the highest, being my captain till the very end and developing into a monster cmf).
Then I kinda got a bit impatient, as building up a stronger team realistically would have took me too much (remember I'm certainly NOT a career expert, I indeed discovered many things just by this run, which was by far my longest), so I started exploiting a bit january renewals, bringing in, among the others, Kessie, Schlager and Christensen.
And then it all started making sense. Finally I was beating lower teams consistently, arriving in the Coppa Italia final (and losing) and qualifying for the Champions League. Then the last two seasons were the most epic ones- I had a team mixed of strong youth players and popular champions like Alisson, Alexander Arnold, Delle Alli, Kane, Gabriel Jesus, Haland, Vinicius Junior and De Light among the others, and other pupils of mine with lesser overalls, but which I was too fond of (left fullback Kelly being my best example, not even Firpo or Theo Hernandez could stole his place, and Schlager.. loved him to death). Finally won Scudetto (decisive match in the derby against Bologna, although unfortunately they were too poor and didn't stand much of a chance) and Coppa Italia, even tho Real eliminated me from CL in the 16th. Felt like the perfect closure to the whole journey, being a powerhouse but still having losses and very well fought matches. Left it in the sequent season, when I had 3 points on the second Fiorentina (and 8 matches left) and I was about to face Barcelona in the CL quarters, probably the best team in the career. Don't know if I'll retake it in future, I doubt it could get any better. Maybe I'll start another one with some personal clear challenge.
Some more general notes on it all:
-It created sub rivalities and matches I was looking forward due to that. Some examples- players who would give me hell, like Inaki Williams in Napoli, Dybala in Juve, Wilson in Fiorentina, Richarlison in Milan or my Milinkovic Savic in Lazio who, on top of his development, felt like playing against a cheat, more or less always scoring against me and winning any single midfeld duel. I was also tempted to buy him but always decided to leave him in Lazio for the fun of it.. then the lovely fucker decides to go to Barça

. Given I should have had to face them, it would have been an even more epic clash just for this.
-Some players, exactly like in glory days Pes, I couldn't use even if they had crazy overalls, like Romagnoli or Fabian Ruiz. Some others, like Kelly and Schlager, or the same Haaland which stayed around 82, never developed in powerhouses but I always felt at home playing them. Christensen wasn't as strong as youth Cardoso or De Light, yet always made me feel he was the more "intelligent" one, perfectly keeping his position and helping me immensely reading defensive situations.
-It created A LOT of epic moments. Like when I beaten Juventus for the first time in I think 4 or 5 season, Or like for example here:
Napoli was between my main enemies for the title. I was winning 1-0, but they were closing me in my box.. it culminated in them hitting that post and me punishing their error with that perfect counter attack finalized by G. Jesus, which made me literally jump from my seat. Ended up winning 2-1 and probably won a large chunk of Scudetto that day.
-Some objectives are straight up broken, like the ones in which you have to play youngsters. But luckily it never got me fired.
Generally, hope it won't sound as a blasphemy, but this whole build up reminded me the days of my Pes 5 ML with Chelsea, when I grinded for titles with everything I had. It was hella fun and it written a virtual football story like I didn't read in a long time, which will certainly stay among my favourites ever. Keep in mind that as I said above I never had a career as long as this one (Fifa 19 ended up being my second most played after 16 just for this), so there was a certain fresh element in it.
Regarding the
gameplay:
Yeah, rythm is bad, especially without many sliders tweaks. I wouldn't say there isn't midfield play but it's all very flipperesque, especially in some matches, against determined teams. As you can already expect there aren't also that many free kicks, although I had some and luckily I also had a decent number of penalties. Also scoring headers is quite hard- not has hard as in 20, but you need a specialist in headers and also a good crosser to have some kind of consistency in it.
Then with the things I particularly liked. For first, the goal variety: superb. Shooting is very satisfying and I casually scored myriad of different kind of goals without forcing myself to. Stats representation is good as well: I think few things excites me more in a football career than appreciating replacing bad players with good ones, and seeing the tangible effect on the field. Just to name one, the moment I replaced my youths keeper with Alisson made all the difference in the world. Or the crosses I scored when I put in A.A, or the solidity Kessie gave me to midfield. One critic could go to pace, which is indeed sometimes hard to spot on average, but really fast players like Vinicius Junior or G. Jesus do stand out a lot, so I guess it's acceptable to me. Don't forget this is also the last chapter without one v one nonsense and midfielders not tracking.
Regarding CPU.. it's tiki takaish for sure, but with one big exception: star players
do stand out, even if in bursts. Good strikers will score you more, good shooters will nail it often, one vs one specialists will take it on you dangerously. I added two examples in this hghlights in 0:38 and 1:43 of what good dribblers might do (even if I wished I saved more stuff from the AI):
The rest are scrappy goals of mine or nice random moments I felt like showing especially from my first seasons. I have some stuff from more recent ones, will probably put it togheter some other time.
I'll end this already lenghty post with a consideration: as I said some days ago here, I don't want to change peoples mind on the game.. you hated it, you most probably still gonna hate it after all I written. You could find another thousand flaws in it and I'd probably agree with most of them. But to me in that particular moment it was the perfect mix between some simulation/depth and some fast action. I just happened to love the small moments of football it gave me and the narrative it generated, and felt like sharing it. But on a general note, given I had this retake when I took a pause from Evo Web, I have to admit: I probably wouldn't have played it if I had read the general opinion about it here. Sometimes I wonder how much negative opinions (or just general ones) influence how we approach a game, regardless of this one.
That said, thanks if you arrived in the end and sorry fo the prolixity, hope it was readable.