I am probably one of the few who like it, i have fifa, and really really like it, i have played around 160 odd ranked games in fifa, so i have played a bit, and i sometimes get extremely frustrated playing fifa, a hell of a lot of interceptions, and a through ball, is never a through ball, its always straight to the defender who is between you and the guy your trying to pass to, only occasionaly does it actually reach him. but dont get me wrong i love fifa, but it was very refreshing to play pes2008 and zip a through ball to the wing and have the guy just bomb on to the dead ball line and get a cross in. replays are pretty poor, agreed on that. dribbling is quite easy, personally i like that, as i have no real problems tackling other people when they dribble. i hear people sayin free kicks are terrible. i practiced them for 20 mins then in my very next game scored a swerving dipping belter with pirlo. my only real gripe is with the lag, it is absoloutly horrendous. makes it virtually unplayable online. apparently their working on a patch and are hopeful on getting it out asap.
just my opinion, everyones is different, but personally i really like it!