In all fairness Deco, you say not all manual players are snobs and while I can safely I wouldn't consider you to act like one, I don't think you can honestly say that holds true for others. Not if this conversation (and others) is anything to go by.
Unless I am missing something and all these folk saying Advanced Shooting is "baby mode" (or at least inferring it) are using Basic. That would just be really, really, really weird.
What I am finding these days is that most of those who are the most critical, the most outraged, of anothers style or control set-up are the ones struggling the most with a specific aspect(s) of the game, so take to lashing out.
But they never, ever, ever, ever post evidence. None. Ever. They just say something and hope it sticks.
They'll just say stuff like "9/10 it is a rocket shot", "defenders score from distance ALL the time", "nobody knows how to defend", "passing is broken", "defending is broken", "the passing is ping-pong", "BABY MODE!" But never, NEVER, post any supporting evidence backing up a claim beyond perhaps one example.