If anyone able to contact the creators of PES11 reads this, I urge you to pass on this feedback. This is a blatantly obvious flaw that breaks the game.
To find the flaw, please do this:
Get the ball in the opposition corner with only one man on you. Now dribble up and down the touchline without run. As long as you are not doubleteamed, you can move up and down as much as you like.
This flaw can also be used a lot in the actual game. The Cat, who initially brought the flaw to our attention, can score goals nearly at will using this. Doing the above is the easiest way to point out the flaw IMO, because it shows how ignorant and powerless the defender is to stop a controlled (ie without holding run) dribble.
The philosophies of football in PES11 are not right and haven't been since PES5. Your enforced punishments for turning sharply while running isn't correct.
In real football it is easy for a player to accelerate and turn with a long first touch, but you also punish them severly for this with a "glitchy", laggy run for a few milliseconds before bursting into a run. It is easy to turn and accelerate from a stationary position, the difficult thing is turning at a high velocity quickly while maintaining momentum. PES11 confuses the two. PES5 understood this but PES11 does not.
IMO the misunderstanding of fundamental philosophies of football means you've had to restrict or retard use of the run to such a drastic point, you've had to give too much power to the non-run dribble to compensate.
Here are some extracts kindly collected by The Cat from a few of us already aware of the flaw whereby defenders will not tackle a non-running dribbler when they only have single coverage:
"@Proofreader & Kaiser – Thanks for taking the time to look into this current gamebreaker. KONAMI need to address it immediately. I doubt they will though, Im pretty sure Jon Murphy has come out and said the demo is final code. (So changes of any note are very unlikely to happen)
HOPE YOU DONT MIND BUT IVE POSTED YOUR MESSAGES AGAIN IN THE HOPE THAT THE BOARD WILL SIT UP AND LISTEN.
The Cat – MASSIVE BUG – Run down the wing without pressing R1 (No one will tackle you) Cross the ball into the box (No one will block you) and get a goal scoring opportunity 3/5 times. THIS IS SHOCKING!
Proofreader – @ The Cat – When I read your comment I thought I’d give it a go. At first I couldn’t make it work, but then one time with Puyol against Robben (I was Puyol) Robben kept backing up and backing up all the way down the pitch to ridiculous proportions.
I tried to figure out if this was a one off or something consistent and I found when I had the ball in the corner flag, I could stroll up and down the wing all day, up and back, up and back, and the defender would NEVER tackle me, just like you stated.
Anyone who doesn’t believe The Cat, do this (on top player). Get a player into the opposition corner, then, without even touching run, jog along the sideline up and back, as long as you stay against the line. It doesn’t work when there is a double team or if you press run.
The defence plays it way too safe by refusing to even go for the ball because they get beaten so easily without run.
I wanted to love this game, it felt a lot better in certain circumstances but if this is the final code it’s clearly broken, and badly, which is so annoying because they’ve done some things really well.
Anyone who bags me because they think I’m hating, well, just try what The Cat mentioned, if you’re half competent you should be able to pull this off no worries.
Kaiser – @The Cat – Dammit it is broken (dribble down the line and no-one tackles you) – I can’t believe it as I had such high hopes and was really enjoying the demo.
I can confirm that not only does this exploit work down the line but you can basically walk into the 18yard box as long as a 2nd player does not join in the tackle i.e 1 on 1 – the CPU will not tackle you!!!!!"
I just don't understand how this could happen after having so long after the near perfect PES5 to improve the game, we have been starved for a brilliant football game for so long.
Please fix this before it's too late, although I'm guessing it's probably too late already isn't it? We want to buy a game that's a challenge and can't be beating by just strolling down the field, you've had so many years after PES5 to create this but we are left continually heartbroken.