Crap, should have tried that. I was playing all my subs anyway, which is why I didn't think of bringing Valdes back in. However, I just noticed another "glitch" I had in my game. In that image I'm playing a La Liga game at Old Trafford....
Turns out I was messing with the LOD Mixer program and put it on Old Trafford and LEFT IT THERE without knowing I'd only play in that stadium. Well today I was playing as Arsenal against Birmingham and I noticed that my last couple games I'd see GLORY GLORY MAN UTD everywhere. Changed it, feel much better now. I must have played about 20 games in Old Trafford without realizing it...such an idiot.