I just spent an evening playing FIFA 08 on PS2. I thought it sucked, to be honest. The players don't move intelligently off the ball on offense, and the key to scoring goal seems to be using the first touch thing, the knock ahead function, and the right stick moves. You can't pass your way to good opportunities. Defending is easy, but about once a game the opponent striker fakes out your center back and gets a one on one chance in the box, which always goes in. The lobbed through ball is almost useless, as is the 1-2 sequence. The crosses hang in the air forever; the ball physics isn't very good; the keeper holds most everything; and I don't care for the shooting system either.
The only possible reason to get the game is the huge selection of teams, and the in-stadium atmosphere which is quite decent; and the management mode is not so bad. But the gameplay still is way behind WE/PES, not matter what anyone says to the contrary. And, the player models are ugly up close.
Also, you have to squint to read the text on the between-game screens in managerial mode. I got a headache trying to do that.
I'm not saying this to bash FIFA, every couple of years I give it a fair go, but I just don't think this version is very good. I'll be trading it in as soon as the next guitar hero is out....