I really don't like the game, I'm afraid.
For a start, I'm hitting 350-yard drives nearly every hole now. I know when you max-out your stats you're going to be good, but what am I supposed to do now when I want a realistic game of golf? Purposefully under-hit every drive? If you play Be A Pro in FIFA, will you be scoring ten goals a game when you up your stats? I don't think so. Otherwise you're blowing realism out of the window. They need to limit how far you can go, otherwise where will we be in a few years? 600-yard drives?
Secondly, I've seen the ball, twice in my last round, drop half into the hole and then come out. The gravity, on Earth at least, is more serious than that. If half the ball drops into the hole, then it won't climb out again (not at the rate it does in this game at least - I wouldn't mind but the "putt preview" shows the ball going into the hole, then you hit it exactly as it's set up and it spins around the hole and goes off for a wander).
Thirdly, there's lots, and lots of glitches. Not just the Tiger Challenge ones that crash your console, but commentary bugs (if you hit a drive over a certain distance they seem to think you've hardly hit it, and will sometimes say "that is a very short tee-shot", only to follow that by "what an excellent tee-shot"), shot-selection bugs (every round my caddy will tell me to pitch to the green using a PW at some point, which will finish 20 yards short of the green - fire the dickhead), putt-length bugs (I've just dropped two shots in a round because, on a 2ft putt, the game chose to give me a 10ft putter, and even at 10% the ball powers through the hole - for God's sake, the game is rendering the fact that I'm 2ft away from the hole, how thick must it be if it doesn't then give me the shortest-distance putter?!)...
Also, lots of things are in ridiculous places. The Pro Shop is under Game Face, for God's sake (?!), and when you compete in a "Daily Tournament" you have to exit the mode (and the calendar) entirely, go to Online, then Stats, then Leaderboards, then press LT, then press up. Just to see the leaderboard. You should be able to just press X on the tournament you want to play and see the leaderboard, not go hunting for it. The design is just shocking in places.
I also hate the fact that the Daily Tournament winners finish on -21. But that's something else entirely (I'd rather be grouped with a percentage of users, so that you've got one or two freakishly good players, rather than see thirty people playing rounds of -21, it's ridiculous).
And I've already explained my hatred for the putting system. The "feature" where you can add/subtract 3ft to the putt from last year might as well not be there, because you can't use it and get an accurate putt. I really liked the way it was before, as did most people I know with the game. Wasn't too easy, wasn't too hard. Yes, you can adapt to the new system, but I had to read a guide to putting off the web because before that I was powering 10ft past each hole; how many people are going to be arsed looking for a guide? Or know where to find it? If I didn't have the net I would have just got a refund. Plus, if you do adapt to it, it gets ridiculously easy. On normal difficulty (and most of the time on the harder difficulty) I was nailing 60ft putts while Tiger was missing by a yard or two.
I only play sports games for realism, and (with 350-yard drives and 60ft putts regular occurances) it seems totally unrealistic to me. More so than last year as well.
Lots of these problems are new issues too, it worries me with EA (and Konami thinking about it) that they seem to happily fuck features up just because they have to add something new. I'm really disappointed, I keep thinking "I'm just in the mood for a game of golf" but after five minutes I'm thinking, this isn't golf.