I think I reached somewhere near 13-14 hours yesterday and only then I saw Vice City lol
Here's my rant back over my coffee!
This is not directed at you in anger but you sparked what goes through my head when people say what you said. We all enjoy our games differently for sure.
This may be a "hot take" to the average every day person who likes those kinds of games. But Crimson Desert isnt that good. its a 7/10 at best IMO. Why?
CONTENT: Yes there is a lot of "content" but there is not much you actually see or do to actually interact with it (which is a contradiction of terms i know). Its mostly the same thing in a different setting i.e. go here, collect thing, talk to person, beat up enemy, talk to person, collect thing. They've added simulations (for example the farm feature) but I dont want to go back to play it, why? because its pointless; there is no reason to, or benefit and it does not fit the rest of the narrative. Its just stuff. Almost like its become a MMO survival sandbox idea with a story bolted on. I have never liked MMO sandboxes for the very same reason. So then if you come from my perspective and see obvious patterns (many people dont or dont care!), its a 5/10. Theyve added more content which has contributed to it being worse and not fixed core issues. Also if you played a lot of Asian games (Japan, China, S. Korea), you notice many "features / content" thats in many other games. You can really see its trying to be too many things at once, rather than concentrating on certain features being very good. Im one of those "see the wood from the trees" kind of people and so are many critics, even if they do get a bad rep these days. (their Mixtape reviews doesnt help...)
PERFORMANCE: If you dont play the PC version and play the PS5 version (even the Pro), the performance is fucking terrible, especially in built up areas or the camp area AND the graphics are extremely fuzzy when this happens. Something that people are bitching about for GTA 6 is actually significantly worse for that game (on the PS5).
STORY: If you play the story of that game, (from day 1 release, not the revamp, which by the way, im not replaying 30 hours to "reignite" the story lol), its terrible. Then you have people say "you dont play CD for the story", then what am I playing it for because the rest of the gameplay is average at best? (Press R1, Press R2, dodge, rinse repeat fights is not fun IMO, so if you didnt like Elden Ring type games, its again, boring).
---
Back to GTA, you are correct, ~30 FPS is not great in 2026. However, if you really try to appreciate the game for what it is and just wander its world, or interact with things, you really see the love put into it. As you have made the comparison, you compare it to CD, CD has things in it but nothing is happening, GTA (and by extension RDR) has things that happen, which makes you feel like you are in a world, you have characters that have personalities (even random people in the street!!!), that you want to know more about, akin to watching a TV program or playing a story heavy game like Until Dawn, Detroit: Become Human or Heavy Rain. Rather than the jarring conversations you see in CD, or any other game like it (I say something like a robot, wait, you say something, wait, I say sentence, wait, I say sentence, wait... its AWFUL lol). These are things that draw it in to the GOTY contention! Critics (and most gamers) enjoy a good narrative, characters they love, serious attention to detail (its insane if you pay attention in GTA 6 and RDR2) and enjoyable moments over performance. If you put it all into buckets, the performance bucket is a 4/10 but the rest of the buckets are full 8-10/10. It easily averages out to a 9/10 and to me the 1st proper AAA game i've played since RDR2.
You also have to be careful blaming Rockstar for the performance, they are really hampered by the consoles and were essentially locked to console only on release by factors we dont want to talk about. They have god awful CPUs in them and GPUs arent much better but when you compare the original price of a PS5 Pro to a comparable PC (in terms of not top FPS but consistant smooth FPS and ease of use), its a no brainer for many people to play a console. And that problem has only got worse since the chip crisis.
One other problem is that if you listen to "content creators" or "streamers", a lot of them farmed GTA Online, NOT GTA Story. A lot of them are exceptionally pissed off there isnt a new GTA Online. IMO GTA Online and RDR2 Online are both boring as fk. If you factor those on their own, it brings the score waaaaaay down! Which makes me think theyve delayed that on purpose so they can focus on the online part to be somewhat like the RP servers that exist and almost get close to the main game in terms of story, core features, world building and immersion. Because once you remove them, the game is subpar at best.
Welcome to my TED Talk. And thank you for listening. I could talk about this stuff for hours, at least it takes me away from my other problems in life